Part 1 of 2.
My wife I visited Italy this year in Aug-Sep for 3 weeks, starting in Catania, and going on to Amalfi Coast and Cinque Terre and elsewhere. Advance planning made it work very well.
2 nights in Catania. Manganelli Palace Hotel from Rick Steves Sicily book: included excellent buffet breakfast. Quite easy walk to the bus/train station with luggage if one takes the (little-used, tree-shaded) bike trail (which includes the one-block long Tony Curtis Street (Via Antonio de Curtis).
- visited Catania fish market.
- day trip to Ortigia (Siracusa). Went by bus, returned by train. (Same day we had visited Catania fish market in the morning.)
1 night in Taormina, Sicily. Took bus from Catania in morning, and stayed at Casa Turrisi from Rick Steves Sicily book. Definitely worth the price to be in city itself, next to Bam Bar and near amphitheatre.
- did Godfather tour. We both enjoyed it: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy/sicily-godfather-private-tour-marco-is-an-outstanding-prestelli-tour-guide
- visited amphitheatre in Taormina.
Our next stop was Sorrento/Amalfi Coast; we didn't want to fly so took the day train from Taormina to Naples, and then the local train to Sorrento. Highlight was to ride what is apparently the only train ferry currently operating in world, between Sicily and the mainland. Rode 2nd class and had no problems.
3 nights in Sorrento. Stayed in a Homeaway apt near train station.
- Day trip to Pompei and Naples. Pompei in morning when it opened, then had pizza in Naples. Took ferry back to Sorrento. (Rick Steves audio guide was very helpful at Pompei.)
- Amalfi Coast tour by Mondo Tours in association with Rick Steves. Excellent: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy/amalfi-coast-excellent-value-shared-tours-mondo-guide-for-rick-steves
Took high-speed Italo train from Naples to Rome.
2 nights in Rome. We stayed at Casa Il Rosario Dominican Convent from Rick Steves Italy book. Very convenient in Monti district, walkable from train station, Colosseum, Roman Forum, Trevi Fountain, Pantheon, Spanish Steps, and very close to bus stop to Vatican. Bought 48-hour ROMA PASS at kiosk at train station when we arrived in Rome.
- Visited Roman Forum the day we arrived, using Rick Steves audioguide.
- Did early morning Vatican Museum / St Peters tour with Through Eternity. Outstanding: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy/early-morning-vatican-tour-with-sistine-chapel-with-through-eternity-tours-excellent
- Walking back from Vatican after tour we visited Campo de’ Fiori and had lunch at restaurant nearby, and then walked to Pantheon, Spanish Steps, and Trevi Fountain.
- Did evening Colosseum tour with another tour company. Well below expectations: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy/vip-colosseum-at-night-tour-by-the-roman-guy-a-great-disappointment
Next we took train to Orvieto.
2 nights in Orvieto. Stayed at Affittacamere Valentina from Rick Steves Italy book. Very clean and comfortable.
- We decided to just relax in Orvieto, dropping our optional idea to do a day trip to Civita. Orvieto was wonderful experience.
- Had an outstanding dinner at Hostaria Posterula: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy-reviews/orvieto-excellent-restaurant-hostaria-posterula
Picked up car at the Orvieto Hertz office, and then drove to Tuscany.
3 nights at Agriturismo I Roseti near Montepulciano. Wonderful stay: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy-reviews/near-montepulciano-outstanding-lodging-agriturismo-i-roseti
- During our stay we visited many towns, including Montepulciano, Pienza, and Montefollonico. (Montefollonico has a rather unique ceramic artist who has her wares in a very old former church). Visited a few wineries; best experience was Uccelliera. https://www.uccelliera-montalcino.it/index-en.php
CONTINUED IN PART 2 of 2