I just scrolled through the posts for the year 2016 and don't find any trip reports on this topic, so I'm asking for info. We're thinking of booking the My Way Italy tour for April 23-May 5 2017. We would really appreciate any reports or feedback of your experiences.
This one was posted in Nov 2015 but I'm sure it would apply: https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/trip-reports/my-way-italy-tour-850c9c75-b73b-48ad-af0b-40d117f53437
You can also do a search on My Way Italy and you see many posts usually in the Italy or RS Tours forums (rather than in Trip Reports)
Take a look at the RS scrapbooks I did that before deciding on the My Way Alpine tour, and then went back and got a lot more information that helped me plan my trip. For specific places, I also used other scrapbooks that went to some of the places on the tour. Not only did it give me a much better sense of places than the trip reports themselves - even when they were longer than they are now, but I was able to contact a couple of the people who were most generous with more information and advice.
Also, on each tour page, there's a "Review" section below the tour description with brief comments from participants.