Please sign in to post.

eSim and Multi-factor Authentication security codes

Hi there!

For those who have tried eSim services in Southern Europe tours (Italy, Spain and Portugal), does the eSim allow you to get security text codes that you can use to verify your identity when you have to login to your credit card or bank account to authorize a purchase at a certain amount, when you need to check your bank and credit card accounts, or when you need to access personal accounts that are password and MFA protected? What was your experience using eSim services and security codes?

Thank you in advance.

Ems

Posted by
2790 posts

To get text codes, you'll still need your usual SIM enabled as that's the one associated with your usual phone number. But have data roaming turned off so you don't rack up charges connecting to mobile data.

You'll access personal accounts via the mobile data provided by the eSIM

Posted by
57 posts

If you cannot receive a MFA by email, an eSIM will not receive a text from your home cell number. If you have WiFiCalling set up from your provider and can use it internationally from a WiFi connection at your hotel, then you can send and receive texts as normal from your main number. An eSIM will usually only give you a data connection from a local provider as indicated when you connect it to your phone.
You could also use an international eSIM as a data signal to use with your home cell number through WiFiCalling. Both SIM & eSIM need to be active, but turn off data roaming so as not to incur charges from your home provider.

Posted by
573 posts

Yarramar said it very well. Here's three more thoughts:

  1. If the OP has a cellphone provider or a cellphone which does not support wifi calling, then that option is out. Fortunately, this can be tested at home before leaving.

  2. If the OP has a recent iPhone, then the second esim (data only), can be used as a substitute for wifi, so that wifi calling will work. But I have not been able to make this work with my recent Android S24 phone.

  3. Another option is to switch the various accounts to doing 2FA via email, if possible. The second esim for data will make email work.

Posted by
2 posts

So many helpful suggestions from this community about eSim and MFA security codes while in Europe. I am looking through these options and deciding which one(s) would would work for my travels. Always good to have back up plans.

Thank you very much!

Ems

Posted by
36 posts

On my trip to Europe a few months ago, I used the combination method already mentioned, that works great if you have a newer phone that can use multiple SIM cards or eSIMs.

My phone carrier is Mint Mobile and they recently introduced a new international option: 30 days of 100 minutes talk and 100 text for $5. I don’t have much travel need for calling/texting (although various travel services/lodgings increasingly do use text messages so it’s super handy), but for $5 I jumped on that plan for one specific reason: To be able to receive MFA codes sent to my US phone number while my phone is with me in Europe.

At $5 that plan does not include international data, but data is what I am really going to use every day in other countries, so what about that? For that I bought and installed a data eSIM covering the amount of data I wanted over a three week trip. It was about $40 from Airalo but other companies can work just as well. Having traveled internationally for 35 years since the age of paper only, I have to say I was a little shocked by how much modern travel now relies on apps and QR codes, even simple things like train, bus, and museum tickets…if you don’t have a smartphone with a good mobile data plan, some things will take more time and hassle.

This worked because my recent phone can store up to 5 eSIMs. I did not have to change the eSIM for the normal everyday US phone number, I only had to add the eSIM for the Europe-only data plan. My phone can use both simultaneously, so if I am using the data eSIM to sign into a US website and it sends a code to my US phone number on file, I receive that through the voice/text eSIM and enter it on the website.

It worked great, with enough data that I never had to worry about finding wifi (such a pain on previous trips), and I would totally do it this way again.

Another approach that might work with some websites/apps: Get away from codes based on text messages or email, and use codes from an authenticator app instead. Although authenticator apps aren't perfect, they are more secure than notoriously insecure email or SMS text. If a website offers passkeys, that is even better and should be your first choice over all the others if available. Just make sure you know how to use them. (Yes, some will say the actual best way is a hardware key like a YubiKey and it probably is, but it's not an easy solution for many people, especially if you aren't comfortable with how to get into your accounts if the hardware key is lost or stolen.)

In other words, if SMS text codes are a hassle, try not to fall back to equally insecure email. Try to upgrade to a more secure second factor like an authenticator app, passkey, or hardware key.

Posted by
2283 posts

Those who use Spectrum for home cable TV or internet service should explore their cellular service. It's quite inexpensive by US standards, and overseas texts are free. It has made 2FA simple during our extensive European travels. (I still get European data eSIMs, though, as the Spectrum overseas data pricing isn't extremely attractive.) Spectrum uses the Verizon network in the USA.