Please sign in to post.

Camino del Norte vs Camino Frances???

We're booked for May and June to tour the Iberian Peninsula. A handful of experienced travelers/friends suggested either of these pilgrimage walks of about 500 miles as a life experience. In fact, the suggestion has arisen so frequently of late that I'm almost taking it as a sign.

We're athletic -- having climbed Half Dome in Yosemite, run half-marathons, and biked centuries and metric doubles. So the physical commitment isn't intimidating. But the time it will take -- about 30 days, depending on how fast we want to go and how many down days we want to sit -- is causing me to go slowly on committing to do such a walk. Communal dinners with pilgrims appeal to us simply for the benefit of meeting travelers from all over. I'm cool on hostals or hostels, and am willing to spend for privacy and occassionally boujie accommodations. And while these walks aren't days of solitude, they are certainly more along the lines of the road less traveled. Seeing a country by walking across it seems to be tugging on my backpacking younger days of decades back.

With all of that said, we have the time so if not now, when? And we'd still have some time to see the highlights of Portgual and Spain.

If you have experienced either or (even better) both walks what are your thoughts? Would you do the walk again? One of our friends who did Camino Frances last year (and he isn't a particualrly effusive person) was dazzled by and gushed about his experience. He plans to go back to Spain this coming year for another walk...

Thoughts? Suggestions? Thanks in advance...

Posted by
2501 posts

Yes, do it.

I'd do it again - did the Frances. No matter how fit you are don't overdo it in the first two weeks as your body adapts to walking every day.

Solvitur ambulando.

Posted by
6501 posts

There are multiple Caminos, not just the two you mentioned. Another might better suit your needs and timeframe. Each is a different length with different terrain. Also, nothing says you need to hike the entire length. To get a Compostela you need to walk at least the last 100k.

Due to having to work and time constraints I only walked the last 120km of the Camino Francés from Sarria to Santiago. We paid for hotels rather than stay in the albergues. That section wasn’t the prettiest and was filled with day trippers who would walk for a couple hours in the morning then get picked up by a bus.

Posted by
8938 posts

Am getting ready for Camino #5 starting in April but will spend 7 weeks walking the Camino Frances starting in Saint Jean Pied de Port. Have walked major portions of the Camino Frances 3 times and the Portuguese Camino starting in Porto, once. Have some friends that walked the Norte and loved it, but it is a bit too hilly for me, though it may be the most scenic route. You may also be interested in the Primitivo Route.

Do join the Camino forum as suggested in an earlier post.

I have a trip report posted here, about my last Camino done in 2022, where I walked from Pamplona to Santiago in 6 weeks. Since I am 67, it takes me longer and I like spending time in all of the towns sightseeing a bit in the afternoons.

You need to walk the last 100 km. to get a Compostela, but you can do this on many of the routes, though a lot of them merge into the Frances at some point except for the Portuguese routes.

I also have a YouTube channel if you want to see a day to day look at the Camino Frances, as well as what many of the places to sleep look like, food, churches etc. https://www.youtube.com/@caminoforeveryone9169/videos

Posted by
307 posts

Thanks everyone for your help. In this internet age, it's still amazing to me how much information is available to review. I appreciate your guidance. As I mentioned in the first post, I somehow can't quite pull the trigger for the full walk...

We're looking at the Mac's Adventures tour that has a beginning leg - from France over the Pyrenees, and an ending leg of 10o kilometers into Santiago de Compostela... It's about 14 days, which is more in line with my attention span -- and then we can still amble about Spain and Portugal for a nice stretch.

If you've got an opinion and/or experience about Mac's, like Mickey Mouse says, "I'm all ears."

Posted by
8938 posts

Just for fun, come join my Camino Q & A zoom meeting on Sun. Look on the Meeting Thread list for more info.

Posted by
6501 posts

We used Macs Adventure when we walked the last 120km from Sarria to Santiago in 2019. Everything went as advertised and we couldn’t have been more pleased with it. Rather than albergues we chose to stay in hotels. Each hotel was clean but basic, but considering we only spent one night at it, they were perfectly fine. A continental breakfast was included at each hotel.

If you wanted to arrange your own lodgings you could save a lot of money by cutting out the middleman. There are a number of companies that will transfer your luggage between hotels for a small fee. Macs Adventure used teetravel as its local provider. I’m sure it’s the company that made all the reservations and it ensured the luggage was transferred. All the towns are very small, so the hotels were small too. Some only had 5-10 rooms.

On our walk the shortest day walk was 19km and the longest was 28km. The Macs representative we dealt with was mike.davidson@macsadventure.com. No idea if he still works for it.

Since we were there (Span) we spent two days prior to the walk in Lugo and a couple extra days in Madrid after the walk.

Posted by
8938 posts

Wow, those are kind of long walks, especially if planned for those who are not sporty or extremely fit. No way would I walk 28 km in a day on the Camino!
Most of my days are around 15-20, with an occasional 21-22km but that is on the Meseta where it is flat.
You can get your luggage easily transferred everywhere, every hotel, every pension, every albergue has envelopes for transfer. For booking accommodations, check out booking dot com. Every budget is there and from Sarria on to Santiago, there is a ton.

Posted by
307 posts

Thanks to everyone for terrific input. I really appreciate this forum and the benefit we get from everyone's experience... I'm bummed that I missed the online conversation this morning. I had it on the calendar, but didn't have an alarm accompany it. Let me know if/when you have another online gathering. Thanks!

I've waffled about booking our hotels and saving money versus using Mac's Adventures, and I'm going with them... It's one less batch of logistics to deal with for our journey. We'll likely do "The Best of" and walk from St Jean Pied de Port to Pamplona, and then from Sarria into Santiago... Cheers to all!