Please sign in to post.

Recent trip- My “glad I took it” and “wish I hadn’t- will rethink next time” list

We just got back from a short trip to Scotland. I tried so hard to pack lightly and thought I was doing a good job with packing. We did carryon only. I took the Rick Steves Two Wheeled Rolling 21” case. It weighed 18 pounds packed at first and I thought I was going to be a proud member of Team Jean (The Lightest Packing Queen) :) By the time I added my toiletries, first aid stuff and electronic items, it went up to over 20 lbs. Some of those items are on the “wish I hadn’t” taken list below. I also took my new Roka Canfield Pack (medium size) as my personal item. That is #1 on my “glad I took it” list.

Glad I took:
1. The Roka Cranfield medium sized backpack. Used as personal item on plane and used several days during trip. Great for storing jackets, small umbrella, souvenirs and water bottle. So versatile and stylish. I may get a small at some point I like it so much.
2. Vessi tennis shoes. Wore them almost every day.
3. Columbia waterproof rain jacket. Wore that almost every day. Held off the rain well and was warm.
4. The Rick Steves two wheeled case. Very light and packs a ton. I did have a bit of four wheeled envy a couple of times in the airport, but we’ll see…
5. Tom Bihn small tray. Got this after hearing so much about it on the forum. Really liked using it and keeping everything in place.
6. Tiny packable Totes umbrella. We had some rain and it was nice to have it and not wear the jacket if it was warm.
7. Foldable hangers. So light, easy to pack and allowed things to dry easily.
8. Pants did great. Two pair Levi’s jeans, one Duluth Trading Co. Dry on the Fly khakis. Wore one pair jeans on the plane. 3 pair pants for 7 days was fine.
9. Merino wool socks
10. Mock turtleneck lightweight sweater
11. Small Kipling cross body purse. Using that was nice on several days. Lightweight and compact.

Wish I hadn’t- will rethink next time

  1. Too many first aid kind of things. Toiletry bag was too bulky and heavy. Neosporin, moleskin, tweezers, etc. The only thing I really used was Tylenol. I don’t need to be super mom prepared for any situation anymore.
  2. Took second Falraven Keb puffer coat. Could have gotten by with the 32 Degrees vest and the raincoat.
  3. Wore Blundstones boots over on plane and only two days. Love these boots, and thought the waterproof factor would be great to have, but in hindsight, for this trip the Vessi’s would have been enough.
  4. Anker portable power bank. My son took one and we only used his once. Unnecessary weight for this trip.
  5. Too many tops. Took two short sleeve. Didn’t wear. Used the other four tops and sweater. Took five total- wore one on plane.
  6. Digital camera. I think I am just going to use my phone from here on out. I have a Panasonic Lumix that is compact and I used it a lot, but it got a bit bulky to tote by the end of the week.
  7. This was a silly one. I thought I would busy myself some on the plane with an adult coloring book and pencil case. Colored one picture lol. Ended up donating the book and the Prismacolor coloring pencils to a local thrift shop before coming home. That idea was an epic fail!

Anyway, I was much better this time lifting the Rick Steve’s bag as compared to the TravelPro Elite bag I gifted my son. But, I think I can do better next trip if I eliminate or substitute some things. It’s a work in progress!

Posted by
1856 posts

Thanks for the report! No matter how many trips I’ve taken there’s always something to learn. I think my fully packed carryon record is around 17lbs. I too strive to emulate Jean, the packing queen. :-)

Posted by
1165 posts

I also struggle to go below 21-22 pounds, although that’s with my Delsey spinner, which weighs a pound or two more than my RS two wheeler. We will see how I do on a November trip to Andalusia and Madrid.

Posted by
3402 posts

Thanks for your packing report. You're right -- packing light is a work in progress. I just can't get down to minimal. If I end up with 20lb Rolling Carry-On and 6lb tote, I've learned to be satisfied as long as I use everything. It's the drugs, lotions and potions, odd and ends and electronics that add up, not the clothes. Cold climates make packing light more difficult.

Posted by
802 posts

You’re so right horsewoofie. I really would love to find a smaller, less bulky adapter, too. The one I have is huge. And I had to carry a battery charger for that camera. The tech zippered wallet case I had was not to my liking. And of course, like you said, the coats and the sweater for the cold.

Posted by
1339 posts

Nice to see someone who reviewed their things after the trip and listed what was not needed. I also do this for myself. I also note the weather i had for the location I was visiting.
OP noted toiletries, first aid, and electric items. I find these are the heaviest of the various things. In fact, clothes alone are pretty light. That other stuff odds and ends is what takes your weight up.

Posted by
1254 posts

MLD, thanks for sharing. You are so right! Clothes, no problem. It's all the extra stuff we bring - tech, 1st aid, ... I've managed to get my spinner down to 17 lbs on the last few trips. I'm on the search for a good spinner that weighs 4 lbs. or less. I was hoping to buy the bag Frank II has recommended while I was in London earlier this year. But, it seems to have been discontinued. So, back to the search.

Good luck finding the perfect combination of having everything you want at that magical weight that doesn't feel like a burden!