Please sign in to post.

Personal Item Holdall for European carriers.

Recently, there was a thread looking for a backpack that would fit many European airline personal item size of 40 x 30 x 15cm.

I had one that was close enough if not packed to tight. But thanks to a frozen shoulder, it makes putting a backpack on, with any weight, excrutiatingly painful.

Time to switch to a holdall. I found exactly what I wanted. The Cabin Max Manhattan Holdall.

It's 40 x 30 x 15 cm expandable to 40 x 30 x 20 cm. So it could do double duty as a single Ryanair bag or a personal item with the European non-discount airlines.

There aren't a lot of internal pockets which is what I prefer. It has a water bottle pocket, a laptop pocket, and a luggage pass thru.

The only downside, of course, is that I can't seem to find it for sale anywhere in the US. Since US airlines personal item size is bigger than most European carriers, the bag manufacturers don't think this smaller bag will sell there.

I bought mine via Amazon.co.uk but it was shipped from Cabin Max. (The Cabin Max website shows it as sold out but it arrived within one day to the UK when ordered from Amazon.)

Nice looking bag Frank II.
I think these bags work well for men. As a woman, with my unmentioned body features, I do better with backpacks. I like RS posters to share new products here. I emphasize personal criteria for choosing a bag.

Posted by
1112 posts

So Frank, do you carry it crossbody or by hand? Sympathies about living and traveling with a frozen shoulder. Are you able to place your bag in the overhead bin? I carry my personal item that is briefcase like crossbody and find it comfortable. I know I’m a minority here but I find shrugging in and out of backpacks very annoying so I’ve never wanted to do either piece of my luggage that way.

Posted by
130 posts

I have a couple RS Euro Flight Bags which are close in size to the one mentioned. Their advantage is the shoulder strap is detachable...have never used it, instead replaced with an Op-Tech SOS (Saves On Shoulders) strap which the wide padded centre section is stretchy neoprene and acts as a shock absorber making the bag feel like a kilo lighter. Have a smaller version on my camera bag as well. Not sure if they're still made but a godsend.

Also, I find a 1kg backpack like the RS Classic less painful with a bad shoulder than hoisting a 2,5kg wheeled bag in/out of the overhead or carrying up/down stairs. How I get in/out of the backpack is put bad arm in first (and whenever possible I stand the pack on a seat or table and back into it then stand up).

Posted by
19470 posts

So Frank, do you carry it crossbody or by hand?

I carry it either...

1) over the handles of my wheeled bag (it has a luggage pass thru);

2) on one shoulder (the good one);

3) By hand.

It seems kind of bulky crossbody.

I can, so far, manage to put my bags in the overhead by letting my good shoulder/arm handle most of the weight.

I do have to put a jacket on via the good shoulder first. A lightweight backpack, such as the packable one I use if I need one during the day, is fine. But since my personal Item can weigh 10-12 pounds when starting my trip, it's too much to try to get on and off with a backpack.

Why so much weight. It's health/medical Items I need to take.

I try not to let health or certain injuries stop me from traveling. Age, however, is gaining ground.

Posted by
165 posts

Looks like a good bag, and not pricy. Glad to hear it has the luggage pass-thru ("trolley strap" as it's called by some bag makers) -- I couldn't tell from the pictures.

So sorry to hear about your frozen shoulder. I had one when I was just a "kid" (mid 40's, I think it was). I hope you are getting good physical therapy; I did and eventually it was like it never happened. I don't remember how long that took -- many months, at least.

GPB - Op-Tech does still make that "shoulder saver," it's on their website.

Posted by
32747 posts

Frank II,

Looks like a great product and hopefully it serves you well for many years. It's slightly smaller than the Tom Bihn Tri-Star which is my usual carry on luggage for air travel. However it's considerably less expensive than the Tri-Star so that's a huge benefit.