Here's my question in a nutshell. If I miss a flight, is there any advantage to having "checked in" or not?
Here's a little background...
We just returned from a trip to Ireland that involved flying from Dublin to Heathrow and then to Los Angeles to get us home. We had booked our Heathrow to L.A. flight when we didn't know all of the details of our trip. Then, a few months later, we decided to visit Ireland and booked the flight from Dublin to Heathrow. As a result, they were not technically "connecting flights." We had to retrieve our checked bags at Heathrow and then take them to the counter to check the bags again for the flight to L.A.
The Dublin flight was late and we almost missed our flight to L.A. We could have checked in for our Heathrow-L.A. flight while we were sitting in the airport in Dublin but we didn't know if we would get to Heathrow in time.