Please sign in to post.

Train Transportation in Germany and Switzerland

We are head to Europe (Germany, Switzerland and Italy) for a month. Part of our travel will be by rental car and train. Our first week we will have a car. When we arrive in Munich we plan on dropping off the car and using the trains to explore the city. We will be in Munich 6 days sightseeing. Then we travel to Luzern and Interlachen for the next 7 days. From Interlachen we will travel to Lugano for 2 days, then on to Cinque Terre for 2 day. We end our trip in Rome for 4 days.

My question is what would be the best rail pass to get. I am struggling to decide the best route to take. Eurail 2 country pass, Eurail Global Pass, or a Swiss Rail Pass. It is my understanding that it is better to buy point to point tickets in Italy. Should I purchase my train ticket from Munich to Zurich in advance?

Can we get seat reservations in advance or should we purchase at the train station before boarding?

Thanks in advance for your assistance!

Posted by
8889 posts

Barb, A rail pass is probably not be the best option.
Munich to Luzern (why do you say Munich to Zürich, when you are going to Luzern?), buy a cheap advance purchase ticket from the DB (German Railways) site: https://www.bahn.com/en/view/index.shtml
The earlier you buy the cheaper it is, but once you buy the ticket is only valid on whichever train you choose, no refunds.
Within Switzerland, a Swiss pass may be advantageous, depending on how many trips you will be making. Sorry, you have to list your trips and do the arithmetic yourself.
In Italy, advance purchase tickets from the Italian Railways site are always cheaper than a pass. Again, once you buy you are committed, no refunds: http://www.trenitalia.com/tcom-en

Seat reservations are a red herring. If you buy a normal ticket (not a pass), the ticket includes a reservation if needed.
Switzerland does not need reservations, neither with a normal ticket nor with a pass.

For more info, read the "seat61" website, especially this page: http://seat61.com/Railpass-and-Eurail-pass-guide.htm

.

Posted by
27236 posts

I'm not sure what you mean about exploring Munich by train. Can you clarify?

That question aside, it appears that your trips looks something like this:

Travel by car to Munich; drop car.
Sightsee in Munich.
Public transportation to Luzern. Side trips??
Public transportation to Interlaken. Probable mountain side trips.
Public transportation to Lugano.
Public transportation to Cinque Terre.
Public transporation to Rome.

If I have that right, you have not much train/bus travel in Germany, just the Munich-to-border leg of the trip to Lucerne, though this seems to involve a Munich-Zurich bus, all of which trip I guess you'd need to pay for (I'm unsure about the part from the Swiss border onward). So I think getting a rail pass that includes Germany will not be cost-effective. This is especially true if you're sure of the timing and are willing to buy that ticket now. (I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong.)

You're spending enough time in Switzerland, and the marvelously-engineered Swiss trains are expensive enough, that you'll probably benefit from some sort of Swiss transit pass. You should start by listing the trips you plan to take within Switzerland (the definites and, separately, the maybes). Check prices on the SBB website, being aware that the initially displayed prices assume that you hold a half-fare card. Choose a departure and change the pull-down box on the next screen to "No Reduction" to see the full fare. With that information you can figure out whether the half-fare card is a good option or whether the Berner Oberland Pass or Swiss Travel Pass would be better. Understand that the various passes vary with respect to how much coverage they give, especially for mountain transportation.

It's true that Italian trains are inexpensive enough that rail passes usually do not pay off in that country. You have just two trips planned, so point-to-point seems the way to go. You can save money by buying the fast-train legs of those two trips in advance. Check schedules and fares on the TrenItalia website.

Posted by
16894 posts

A Eurail Global pass is overkill, since it cover 28 countries. These are the more likely options. There's more math that you can do, if you want to compare lift discounts and 2nd-country ticket prices.

Swiss Travel Pass for 8 consecutive days (which should get you as far as Lugano, even if it doesn't cover your last day there): $382 in 2nd class + German and Italian tickets. This gives you greater coverage and discounts on the mountain rides around your home bases. See our coverage comparison. You could also start the pass on your second day in Luzern, if you're buying a separate ticket into the country.

Eurail Select 2-Country pass for 5 travel days at $239 in 2nd class (sale version) + either German or Italian tickets

Eurail Select 3-Country pass for 6 travel days for $367 in 1st class (sale version) + a couple of Italian seat reservation fees

Munich-Luzern advance discount tickets can be as cheap as €29. Without booking advance discounts, Italian tickets will cost a maximum of $100 per person in 2nd class.