Please sign in to post.

Spinner wheels?

I am sold on spinner wheels on my luggage. They are so much easier to maneuver than traditional wheels. Are spinners more vulnerable to breakage? I don't want to end up w/ a tripod after all that cobblestone! Thanks!

Posted by
23276 posts

I agree, they are easier to maneuver on flat, smooth surfaces, like airports, but when it comes to cobblestones, rough concrete sidewalks, streets, etc. it is a whole different issue. The wheels are smaller than most two wheel bags and tend to get stuck in cracks. Of course, the wheels are more vulnerable to breakage because they more exposed than the two wheels which are often partly embedded in the luggage. Not a good choice IF you have to deal with a lot of rough surfaces as is more common in Europe. On the other hand, you may not have much choice since it looks like most luggage is being made with four wheels. Recently started looking for a replacement for a very old two wheel bag and options appear to be limited.

Posted by
2788 posts

As someone who flies often, I have seen lots of folks in airports with the type of suitcases that have 4 small wheels on the bottom. They sure look like they work well on that nice flat, smooth surface you find in airport terminals. However, as someone who goes to Europe very summer for the last 10 years, soon to be 11, I have traveled to so many places that do not have flat, smooth surfaces. I can only imagine the problems that those 4 small wheels would create in so many of those irregular surfaces. I have been using a RS 21" roller suitcase forever and have never had a problem in dragging it all over Europe on all kinds of surfaces. If someone is looking to purchase suitcases to use in Europe, they should at least check out the RS Travel Store elsewhere on this web site. Lots of choices with great warrantees if purchased from the RS site. Happy travels.

Posted by
4156 posts

When moving fast as I usually am in train stations and airports and on rougher sidewalks and cobbled streets, I roll my bag tilted like you would a 2-wheeled one. If it's really bad, I carry it, but not far. The only time I keep it upright on 4 wheels while moving is when I'm on smooth floors walking at a slower pace, on moving sidewalks or when I go up and down escalators. On several trips with 2 different spinners I have had no problems. I can't imagine that there would be so many Europeans traveling with spinners if they had a lot of trouble with breakage.

Posted by
1116 posts

I've brought both types and I've decided to stick with the 4 wheeler. As others have mentioned, you can tilt it as needed for cobblestone streets and it works no problem. And if 1 wheel breaks off, at least you have 3 others to compensate with ;D

Posted by
188 posts

When I bought new luggage last year I went through the 2 vs 4 wheels thing for sometime until I decided on 2 wheels because I saw several reviews from people who had opted for 4 wheels, only to have airline baggage handlers find ways to damage one or more. And I agree with the posters on rough surfaces in Europe...lots of them! But 4 wheelers are certainly popular so it will come down to your personal choice. I have also been using a RS 21" 2 wheeler for years and one wheel became damaged while running for a plane in the Atlanta airport. I called RS Customer Service for assistance in finding a replacement and they sent me a whole new wheel set free of charge. My suitcase was several years old at that point so I was surprised and happy with the service. RS Customer Service rocks!

Posted by
348 posts

I reluctantly had to park several blocks from my hotel in Nerja, Spain since parking spots were at a premium. I was astounded at what a piece of cake it was walking my spinner that distance, compared to the traditional roller. Fortunately, the cobblestones were flanked by a smooth surface. It gave me a whole new attitude about parking a distance from my destination.