Please sign in to post.

Ridley Scott's "Napoleon"

If you're both a film and European history buff, such as myself lol, than I'm sure the upcoming Napoleon biopic starring Joaquin Phoenix and directed by the legendary Ridley Scott is on your radar.

The trailer for the film just dropped yesterday and I thought I'd share it in General Europe (pun intended) section for those who are interested - https://youtu.be/OAZWXUkrjPc

I must say the trailer makes the film look a bit like an action movie on par with the likes of Marvel, but the production value looks very impressive, although I must say Scott has been up to his old tricks of shall we say "exaggerating" the history... cough Pyramids cough, but I'm willing to over look minor infractions.

All in all looks entertaining enough, hope they don't shy away from depicting some of the (often overlooked) atrocities that Napoleon perpetrated, let's just say he has a very bad reputation in Spain for a reason.

Posted by
4624 posts

Can't wait. I've only been to France once but it gave me an appreciation of French history that makes me want to take a deeper dive. Planning trips around books and movies is my biggest inspiration.

Posted by
4184 posts

Planning trips around books and movies is my biggest inspiration.

For me I come for the books/movies, but stay for the history!

Posted by
4295 posts

Thank you for the link Carlos. We were in Israel in March and didn’t realize Napoleon made it to Tel Aviv and after being defeated, left his ill soldiers behind in an Armenian monastery to die.
Also, on the island of Lokrum, off the coast of Dubrovnik, there is an abandoned fort that Napoleon built. There is no record of him actually being there though.
We are really looking forward to seeing this movie. Can anyone recommend a good book about Napoleon? I only need to read one but would like it to be a good one.
Thank you in advance.

Posted by
129 posts

I did not know about this film, however I read the Andrew Roberts biography on Napoleon not long ago and then visited his tomb on my last trip to Paris. A very intriguing, complicated person. In many ways the first modern dictator, but still mostly revered in modern, democratic France.

Posted by
4184 posts

I also second the recommendation for Andrew Roberts' Napoleon: A Life, a very complete biography. I believe it's also available as a audiobook on audible.

Posted by
1077 posts

Thank you, Carlos, I am greatly looking forward to this movie. I have been intrigued by NB for years. I hope it's as close to reality as possible. Joaquin Phoenix, Mark Bonnar (Shetland) and Ian McNeice (Doc Martin) are in it--some of my favs.

Posted by
9436 posts

Wasn’t on my radar, didn’t know about it, so thank you Carlos. I’m sure it will be very Hollywood-ized but still enjoyable.
I’ve always been fascinated by Napoleon.

I highly recommend visiting Malmaison, just outside Paris, the estate where he lived with Josephine.

Posted by
4184 posts

I hope it's as close to reality as possible

Well... from the trailer they definitely used some creative license. Napoleon probably did not shoot at the Great Pyramid of Giza lol! Joséphine's hair looks a bit off for the era, but probably trying to allude to her childhood in the Caribbean.

But I'll admit it has to be a balance between entertainment and historical accuracy.

Posted by
4184 posts

"cough Pyramids cough"... Historical correct though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Pyramids

Well not the way they are depicting it in the film, where they are fighting right next to them and they shoot the Great Pyramid with cannon haha.

The so called "Battle of the Pyramids" (renamed later by Napoleon) actually took place 15 kilometers from the Pyramids, they were just about visible in the distance. After Napoleon became emperor, the battle was given legendary status and used as propaganda, many French paintings later erroneously depicting the battle right next to the Pyramids (as it is shown in the trailer).

Posted by
1453 posts

The 1970 film Waterloo (Rod Steiger, Chris Plummer) is a must if you are into this epic battle and period of French history. Shows many historically accurate (and a few less so) details of the battle. Filmed in Ukraine, the vast, sweeping troop movements were filmed using thousands of Soviet soldiers costumed as French, British, and Prussian soldiers.

Posted by
2693 posts

I will need to see this, and I wonder how it will compare to the incredible 1927 silent film Napoleon by Abel Gance--I had the pleasure of seeing the 5 1/2 hour restored Brownlow version of it (and there is now even a 7 hr version being edited) in a gorgeous Art Deco theatre in Oakland, with full orchestral accompaniment, and for the final battlefield scene they had installed 2 additional screens that opened up to show it in all its glory.

Posted by
6713 posts

And another. It's Napoleon: A Life by Andrew Roberts, Viking (2014). Amazon's selling the hardcover for $152 which is ridiculous, look for a paperback or Kindle or your public library. It's 800+ pages, well written though some parts may interest you more than others. If you get the hardcover it can be used later as a doorstop. ;-)