Please sign in to post.

Re-entering the U.S. after being in Europe

I've lived in France for several years. Earlier this year, I had to make a brief emergency trip to the U.S. and, while flying, had spent some time thinking about the U.S. Dept. of Agriculture question regarding whether I had visited a farm while out of the U.S.

I understand why the question is asked: to find out who may be carrying seeds, spores, pollen, or microorganisms on their person that could cause problems for U.S agriculture.

The problem is that that question really presumes it is being asked of tourists rather than residents of a foreign country. Implicit in the question is that one would be bringing back the same shoes and clothing one was wearing while visiting a farm. It's less likely that would be the case for residents overseas than for tourists. And, given the search and time investment likely accompanying a "yes" answer to such a question -- even if one has bathed several times and none of the items (clothing and otherwise) one is bringing to the U.S. has spent time on a farm -- I would think it's easy to understand why an expat from the U.S. might be reluctant to answer "yes" to such a question.

But I was surprised to find, when I entered the U.S. earlier this year via Chicago's O'Hare airport, that the farm question was not asked. In fact, I never was handed a form to fill out by a flight attendant as had happened on so many previous trips from Europe to the U.S.

So, as a I contemplate another visit to the U.S. to be with family and friends later this year, I wonder if that question and that questionnaire will again return or if it has been dropped altogether.

I would be curious to learn of the experiences of other recent returnees to the U.S. from Europe.

Posted by
1883 posts

Several years ago I did some hiking in Switzerland and the trails often bisect the farms. I answered yes to that question and was directed to the agriculture person. She took my shoes and dipped them into a tub of disinfectant solution. Took all of maybe 10 minutes.

Posted by
106 posts

Thank you for your response. So, other than that experience from several years ago, would you have any more recent experiences you could share?

I'm specifically interested in whether that short questionnaire one was required to complete upon entry to the U.S. still is being required. That would help me understand if my experience a few months ago at ORD was an outlier or the new normal.

Posted by
4744 posts

Good question. I just realized that I was not asked that question this week when clearing customs and immigration at Shannon after 10 days in Ireland, although I was expecting it.

Posted by
9109 posts

I never was handed a form to fill out by a flight attendant as had
happened on so many previous trips from Europe to the U.S.

That's because most airports have switched to electronic kiosks. But it just semantics as the machines ask you the same exact questions as you would find on the form; including the farm question.
It's always best to be truthful at border crossings. If an immigration/ customs official suspects you are being deceptive it will hold you up even more.

Posted by
8159 posts

I passed through Ohare all the time. I think I saw that question on the automated kiosk. It is never asked by the customs border patrol agent. Perhaps only if you answered yes on the kiosk then the border agent will grill you

Posted by
3428 posts

I believe (not totally certain, but about 90%), that this question was asked to help deter persons bringing in huff and mouth and mad cow disease organisms during major flares abroad- thus the shoe treatment. Those diseases are now under better control (both here and abroad).

Posted by
106 posts

Returning to Boston on May 30, even passengers without Global Entry were not required to fill out those forms because everyone gets to use machines and input their answers there.

Posted by
23601 posts

That has been a standard question for years and still is. Just saw it last week returning from Canada. However, on the electronic screens there is a box --- No to All Questions -- at the very top. Therefore if you just hit that box you don't read each question. I am guessing most just hit that box and move on.

Posted by
11742 posts

We use the Mobile Passport app and it has the question. Returning a few weeks ago we answered in the affirmative as we had hiked in the UK and France near sheep and cows. The agent that checked us in said nothing about it. Ditto when we returned the the US after living in Italy for several years. We answered “yes” on the kiosk questionnaire but there was no follow-up. Maybe France, the UK, Switzerland and Italy are of no concern at present. It was not too long ago that Mad Cow disease was causing havoc in the UK.

Posted by
892 posts

The itinerary for Day 7 of the RS Basque Tour states: This afternoon, we'll head to a sheep farm where we'll learn firsthand the importance of sheep to the Basque culture and make our own yogurt.

Posted by
492 posts

The question isn’t necessarily standalone - You get asked where you were, along with what you did while there or what you may be bringing back. If a country currently has no existing agriculture risks (such as outbreaks of livestock disease) it’ll probably not be too big an issue and they may not even blink an eye at your answer.

Posted by
8919 posts

I have a friend who worked as one of the DoA inspectors at a US airport. Part of what you don't know is that their level of interest is based on the continually tracking of agricultural disease outbreaks all over the world. So if they have current intelligence about something having do do with (for example) sheep in Tuscany, they are going to scrutinize people who have been there and those that answer yes to that question more closely.

Posted by
31 posts

We had to complete the form with the question about visits to a farm last week at Dulles Airport outside Washington, DC. For some reason, they have removed the mobile entry machines at IAD and the result was an hour long wait at border control.

Hadn't been on a farm in France or Germany, but a few years ago we were on a farm in Wales. As the other poster said, our boots were dipped in some liquid and we were on our way with a warm "welcome home."