Please sign in to post.

Planning next vacation and need help narrowing things down: Iceland, Ireland, or Scotland?

Hello all! I've been cruising the internet asking this question in web browsers and reading the answers when others asked this, but I haven't gotten a great answer based on my priorities. So I thought I would ask here.

I am trying to plan my next vacation (in about two years... I need to save for it which means I need to figure out where I am going). I really wanted to go to Iceland, but after doing some research, I am put off by the cost. So I expanded my search to consider Scotland and Ireland. So now I am trying to decide between Iceland, Ireland, and Scotland.

Concerns I have (aside from cost) are two fold. First, my daughter will be going with me. She is vegetarian but also a foodie. So I want to be sure we travel someplace where she will enjoy dining since that's her favorite focus with travel. Second, my mom may or may not go. She has mobility issues and I thought she was done with travel with our trip to Germany last year (she really enjoyed herself and, except for the train stations with steps, it was easy enough getting around with her wheelchair and cane). But she knows I am planning a trip and I've overhead her talking to her other family and mentioning she hopes she's able to go.

Iceland looks stunningly gorgeous! I could rent a car and explore which makes it accessible to mom if she goes. But it is also very expensive and seems like there isn't a lot to do aside from sightseeing nature (which is fine, I like that, but I love historical places too). I worry about food there too, not only for my vegetarian daughter, but my mom won't eat fish or lamb and it seems like that's the main staple. This might be a place I have to go back to alone, later.

Ireland seems like a fun place with a lot to do and a lot of history. My daughter suggested Ireland. But, if we take mom, she's already been there. She will say she doesn't care, she would still want to go. But I hate to repeat things for her this late in her life--I kind of feel like it's my duty to help her live the dream she and dad had to travel the world and see as much as they could. He died before they could do that. I think I will have to rent a car there to get around and driving doesn't look relaxing for me (I hate driving as it is, let alone on the other side of the road, on a narrow road, shifting with my left hand). Plus, I want to have beer if we go there and I am a lightweight so I won't drink a drop if I am driving anywhere. But I wonder if they have bus day trips we could take to save me from driving.

Scotland seems to be a good mix of pretty like Iceland with history like Ireland. As a bonus, I would like to go there because I am Scottish on my dad's side. It sounds like the transportation is better than Ireland and there are more varied options to get around. Plus, they have curry and vegetarian haggis... so the vegetarian issue is solved. There is also the bonus of none of us having been there. It seems like the best pick all around, but is it accessible? If it's similar to Germany, I will be fine. I can push a wheelchair up hills and lug it on to a train. It's heavy, but I've been there, done that. Although in Germany, the men were gentlemen and often offered to help me with the chair (so I did get some help form the locals too).

The other option is a few days in Iceland just to see the highlights and then connecting to Scotland or Ireland. I saw in the same video I mentioned before that Iceland Air does some kind of special like that. It might be a good hybrid. But I think I would need to make the trip longer to make that an option. Speaking of which, I am thinking 7-9 days total (longer if we do the stop in Iceland).

Anyway, for anyone who has been to these places and can shed some insight on things that would help me narrow things down, I would appreciate it. Again, my main concerns are handicap accessibility, cost, and food options. Thanks!

Posted by
2013 posts

I am a vegetarian and I love Ireland because restaurants are required to offer a vegetarian option. It is also such a beautiful country with so much to do. If you are uncomfortable about renting a car plan your trip where there are public transportation options available and/or occasionally hire a driver for the day.

Posted by
1137 posts

I’m currently in Iceland, was in Scotland last week, am vegetarian, and have mobility issues. ;) I also visited Ireland 19 years ago. I’d say Ireland is probably best for mobility. Iceland and Scotland both had plenty of vegetarian options, I wasn’t veg 19 years ago but I do remember not liking several of my Ireland meals. Edinburgh is worst for mobility - hills, cobblestones, crowds. Iceland flat with lots of paved paths so good on that front, but many of the Gold Circle and South Coast sites are far from the parking lots. Some of Thingvillir and Gullfoss are wheelchair friendly, Geysir not so much. On south coast Seljalandfoss was sort of wheelchair friendly, Skogafoss more so and Reynisfjara not at all. It’s MUCH easier to drive in Iceland than Scotland or Ireland. I would rate all 3 countries in my personal “ok” category - I liked them but don’t feel need to come back. Please feel free to message me if you have any questions.

Posted by
1137 posts

Also adding - we did the Iceland Air stopover from Glasgow and it’s great! Also lots of hamburgers in Iceland and the occasional chicken nugget. Also in Scotland we did a lot of UberX that can accommodate a wheelchair. Uber has a “Uber assist” category that sends drivers specially trained to assist limited mobility folks and it’s usually cheaper than a regular Uber.

Posted by
8157 posts

I have not been to Ireland but have been to both Iceland and Scotland. I loved Iceland and would definitely go back there but it is much more expensive than the other two places. You could certainly do a layover there with Iceland, and it doesn't even need to be 7-9 days. 3-4 full days would give you a good experience.

Scotland has an incredible amount of history, which is one reason I loved it so much. Yes, there are issues with the roads on some of the islands (although I did not have any problems driving on the mainland) but nothing insurmountable. The scenery there is breathtaking and very diverse. There are places on the islands that remind me a bit of Iceland - that same type of craggy, dark green hills and stones (sorry, it's hard to describe). Food is good and like Ireland, vegetarian options are on every menu, along with non-seafood items in most restaurants. The cost was much cheaper than Iceland, I can definitely tell you that. You can find B&Bs, hotels and guest houses for under £100 in most places on Scotland (the lowest I paid was for £50 for a single room on Skye) but I think I paid the equivalent of $150 a night in Iceland and that was 5 years ago. Most places in Scotland also include breakfast in the price, which is an additional savings.

In terms of accessibility, you're going to have problems not only with all three destinations but usually with most places in Europe. Let's face it - they're older and are simple unable to conform many buildings to allow accessibility. But mostly that is going to apply to some of the sights, and not hotels or restaurants in most cases.

Posted by
28247 posts

I would feel terribly constrained by having only 7-9 days in Scotland--the only one of your possible destinations I've been to. It's a beautiful country with significant transportation challenges that can really slow you down. In terms of getting around to the gorgeous rural areas without driving, you might look at the day trips and multi-day tours offered by Rabbies. I haven't take any of their tours, but several posters here have been pleased with them.

Posted by
8157 posts

I'm sorry, but I thought you were saying 7-9 days in Iceland and then would travel to wherever. I agree with acraven - 7-9 days is not very long to have a fulfilling time, especially since your time will be somewhat constrained by your mom's mobility issues. I would stick with one destination only and eliminate Iceland (unless it's your sole destination).

I also agree that Rabbies tours (or others) would be a good option for you all. They have a very good reputation on this forum and some really interesting tours. https://www.rabbies.com/en/scotland-tours

Posted by
76 posts

Thanks for the help so far. This is great information, especially from you Kelly'd Rather be Traveling. You are a great help with both of my main concerns with mobility and food! And thanks Laurie for letting me know about Ireland having options on ever menu. Maybe that's why my daughter suggested it.

Mardee, thanks for the tips on prices and other information. It's good to know that the scenery might rival Iceland. It will help me decide, if I split the trip, what to see in Iceland vs what to see in Scotland (if I go to Scotland). Yeah, I remember pushing that wheelchair up hills in Bavaria last year. It's a good workout for me. Actually, going downhill it worse. Going into buildings isn't an issue. I should have explained my mom walks slowly with a cane (very slowly) I use the wheelchair for any distance so we move quicker and she doesn't tire out. In Germany, I would push her places and leave the chair outside while she slowly walked in. She skipped a few places with a lot of stairs.

And Acreven, I know my vacation idea is on the short side with 7-9 days. But that's the reality of how much time I can get off work (and have time to recover). If it's any assurance, I've done this kind of short European trip twice before with eight days in England a few years back and nine days in Germany last year. It's short, but it works for what I can do and I have no regrets. But I may need to go back to some places. :)

Posted by
2013 posts

I second Rabbies tours in Scotland. They are small group van tours and their offices where you meet for the tour has a great cafe. I had breakfast there before the tour and at the end of the day purchased my to go dinner there to take to the hotel to eat. I took the tram from the airport to my hotel Premier Inn York Place. The tram stopped right across from the hotel. In the morning I took a bus to see the Yacht Britannia and the Rabbie's office was only a short walk away (but up a hill I think.) I enjoyed the pub across from the hotel. I have wonky knees and all the walking, especially on cobblestones or up & down hills, did make it worse But I was traveling solo and did manage by scheduling lots of rest stops at tea shops & pubs!

Posted by
2690 posts

As much as I love Iceland (going for the 5th time next month), I think for you a short stopover would work best. Then if you want to go back, give it the time it deserves. Our first stopover was a 3 day stay and we were hooked! Yes, Iceland can be expensive, but it doesn't have to be. There are lots of options. Don't worry about the food. While there is a lot of fish and lamb, there are plenty of other dishes such as pizza, chicken, etc. Our adult daughter is dairy and gluten free and in her 3 trips there, she has eaten very well. A wheelchair definitely makes things a bit more difficult, but your mom could still see so much! If you did a 3 day stopover, you could spend one day in Reykjavik itself and then do a 2 day one night tour of the south coast. You can easily self drive this. The thing with Iceland is tourism has boomed, but lodging/rental cars/etc have not kept up so you really need to book lodging about a year in advance. This is especially true if you are trying to keep costs down. There are discounts for a few things, such as cars, so planning in advance lets you find those deals and get the most for your money.

Posted by
76 posts

Thanks again for the help! I spent the afternoon and evening crunching the numbers (looking up airfares, hotels, car rental prices, tours, etc) and I checked out Rick Steves' travel guides for all three places from the library and skimmed them. After looking in general and calculating prices, it seems like going to just one place will be the most economical choice. And with my short vacation, I would get the most out of it by staying in one place. Iceland is more expensive than the other two, but because I would rent a car and drive while there (vs the other places where I would do more paid bus tours), Iceland ends up not being that much more. Plus, you very helpful people set aside my fears about food and accessibility in Iceland. Since it was my first pick all along, I think I am just going to go there. Now to buy my own copy of Rick's book on Iceland so I can start planning! I can not thank you all enough, you were very helpful!

Posted by
1959 posts

There's nothing at all wrong with Iceland, but it is a bit of an Instagram darling. There's a lot of stuff there that's not particularly charming. I have a buddy who was a park ranger, in locations both far north and far south. His take is that as you get closer to the poles, things become progressively more utilitarian. Reykjavik is a small city. Where it's ringed with suburbs. You're going to find a lot more corrugated tin and a lot less charming gardening. I'm not talking about poverty tin, more like aesthetics don't matter tin. And not everywhere you look in the countryside is pretty. There's a lot of stuff that's fairly plain.

Iceland is a good place to go if you have a specific outdoor itinerary of places you want to visit and things you want to do. And you're not worried about being scuttled by poor weather. I surf and ride bikes. I would take a surfing trip to Iceland, or go bike packing there 100%. But as a sole country destination on a more general Europe trip? I'd rather see beautiful Scottish cities and villages and pretty Scottish country. Or sublime and deeply historic Ireland. Activities will be more varied, and there's more stuff coming from different angles that's mind-blowing in those places.

Posted by
2571 posts

I would look at the multi day tours offered by Rabbie’s. They can help you choose the best one for your group: https://www.rabbies.com/en/scotland-tours?gad=1&gclid=CjwKCAjwg-GjBhBnEiwAMUvNWyc3yI6AYoyYeAe4qyW3gE9XczYYNB78lObzGd0W7u4eyCRN54fOCBoCqdMQAvD_BwE#Scotland

I haven’t been to Iceland, but I’ve been to Ireland and Scotland. Both are lovely. The people in Scotland are the friendliest I’ve met anywhere. They will bend over backward to help you.