Sorry I'm coming in late, but that Washington Post article was, at least for me, only available online by subscription. It took me a long time to run down a copy I could read. And it took me over a week to get my own copy of Lonely Planet from the library. So, I can finally comment.
My comments:
“Even though the Internet pulses with constantly updated information, it can overwhelm and delude people like me. “
The Internet does not overwhelm me. I know how to process information (the more the better), and I don't need someone else to tell me where to go. And I'm not deluded (whatever that means).
A guidebook is an excellent read for anyone planning their first trip to somewhere new. Maybe their first, but not beyond that.
What I agree with:
Less is more. I'd much rather rinse out a couple of items each night than carry a 35 lb suitcase.
Don't be afraid to miss "don't miss" destinations – Dachau, for example, is a "don't miss" destination in Munich, but I missed it for years and survived. When I finally went there, having heard so much about it, I was underwhelmed.
Aim for balance – Too many people try to see too many things in too little time. Don't make your vacation a series of one-night-stands. Spend a little time enjoying the current place instead of rushing off to the next.
What I'm neutral about:
Always ask locals where to eat. It can sometimes be advantageous, but it is not necessary. In 125 nights, I've had restaurant advice five times, one volunteered, four on request. They were all good advice. Most of the time though, if I'm in a small town, and I just walk around reading posted menus, and that has worked for me.
What I disagree with:
Rent a car if public transit is spotty I've never found public transit spotty enough to justify the cost of renting a car. Most people just don't understand public transit.
Pay luggage fees in advance on budget airlines. Don't use budget airlines, ever. There is so much to see in any local area in Europe; you don't need to fly around.
Call the local tourism bureau. Find the tourism bureau's website. There is so much information there. Use their email to get answers to your specific quetstions.
Splurge on a nice hotel your first night. Absolutely not. You don't have to splurge, ever, to stay in a “nice” hotel, even for the first night.
Buy the book I absolutely disagree here. Except for “maybe” the first trip, guidebooks are a waste of money. I know this is heresy on this site, but I've found it to be absolutely true.
For my first trip to Germany, I bought a German Rail Pass, from Rick. (I didn't lose money with the pass, but I didn't save, either.) With the railpass Rick sent a copy of ETBD Germany. I had already made all of my reservations, so it didn't really help. I've had the guidebook for almost 20 years and never used it. I find my reservations using the Internet.
I feel completely confident to find accommodations on the internet.
Well, mostly. In 2012 I went to Prague, and, as usual, I found accommodations using the Prague website. However, I was so completely “deluded” by bad reviews of the places I found, so I used Rick's guidebook for Prague. The place I found (Lida) on Rick's guidebook was completely satusfactory, but I can't help but wonder if the other places would have also been good.
I want to go someday to Tuscany, which I know nothing about, so I bought Rick's Italy guidebook.
But for Germany, I don't need a guidebook.
(to be cont'd)