Jim is correct in that it not simple, but I don’t agree with some of the generalizations and details. I am also no immigration lawyer, I just live in one country and know and understand what I need to know and understand to remain legally in this one country. Not all of my situation and observations of the situations of others here jibes well with Jim’s generalization.
There is a rise in nationalism in Europe and borders are getting tighter and there are calls to send all the outsiders home. I suspect before the end of the year a few countries will begin actively exporting foreigners. So Jim's attitude isnt unusual. And, its fair. This isnt my country so i never complain. I follow the rules and will stay as long as I am welcome and not a moment longer.
Not sure how many are lying. Doubt any significant number. It would be like calling Jim’s inconsistencies in his post lies. No, the forum is full of statements that are incorrect. That doesn’t make them lies.
I am not a citizen of the EEA and I have a legally registered business in an EEA country. I am not lying.
Several European countries have Nomad Visa programs. The few I know about have length of stay limitations (1 or 2 years).
Retired and people with passive income do make up most of the American expats where I live.
There are countries in Europe that will give you residency if you purchase real estate. There was once several in the EU that would but I think most of the EU member states have ceased the practice … but I can’t say that for certain. Some outside of the EU I know still do it.
If an American wants to work in my country, then he must apply for a local work permit. I have an expat friend that owns a few local businesses and imports all her workers and it’s not a terrible process. Those that are currently here can renew almost indefinitely. I know workers that have been here legally for more than ten years. Every country will be different.
Not sure the definition of a short-term visa in the context of Jim’s post. Many countries do offer 1-year visas. Is that short term? Until recently my country issued 3-year visas that were renewable; and most often were renewed. That is how I began.
Yes, working within the system to stay here legally can at times be a pain in the …. If you can hang in, legally, for 5 years then the EU does have a permanent residency process. I don’t know the details. I will look at it next year when I have my 5 years done. US optimisim is a beautiful thing that can produce nearly 2 Liberty Ships each day, with a loaded displacement was roughly 14,200 tons and a footprint the size of a European football pitch when it has to.
The post jumps around between EU EEA Schengen and Europe, so I have two other suggestions. Georgia and Albania both allow US citizens to stay for 365 days. With Georgia you can leave at the end and re-enter the next day. In Albania I think you have to leave or 90 days to reset the clock. But again, I am not immigration attorney so don’t trust a word I have said.