During my recent trip to France I had varying experiences.
I went to the Louvre 3 times, all, of course, timed entries. The middle visit I inadvertently booked for a Sunday and even with timed entries there were lines outside and madness inside - looked like it used to be, lol. The other 2 times there was not much of a line at entry and I felt the crowd was spread out (except for the special exhibition).
For the Orsay, yes, it made a huge difference both in entry lines and lack of crowding inside.
The Musee Jacquemart-Andre - very crowded even with timed entries and the special exhibit there (Botticelli) was jammed. (But it also meant that we were ready to leave in time to be seated early for lunch in the cafe which was a wonderful experience!)
Rodin and Orangerie - no lines, no crowds (again except in the special exhibition)
Carnavalet - recently reopened and they somehow did not plan for crowd control either outside waiting for timed entries OR inside in security. It was a mess. I noticed no difference inside where it was moderately crowded. I did not do the special exhibition here.
I'm good with timed entries. Anything that can spread out the flow of people over the day is a good outcome in my view. I hope it is making it easier for the security folks in the big museums and a more pleasant experience for the rest of us!