Wow, who knew posting a simple travel tip from Rick would create such a lively debate? :-)
(My thoughts too! I'm holding back the chuckles.)
Still, I can't tear myself away, and I feel unfaithful abandoning poor Rick on this issue since I tend to disagree with him on several important issues... Boy, do I have questions...
How is a noisy refrigerator an "everyday sound" that I should be able to deal with at nighttime? I usually sleep in my bedroom, not in my kitchen.
How is a noisy refrigerator a sleep aide? "White noise" it is NOT. These cheap little things don't provide continuous and pleasant audio; they are poorly insulated, so if they are on, their cheap little compressors cycle off and on day and night, cycling off with a "clunk" sound, and then rattling like crazy when they come back on.
If a fridge does get moldy, why would a guest be charged? Do housekeepers not clean inside the refrigerator anyway?
Has anyone you know actually received a hotel bill that included a charge for replacing a mini-fridge, or even seen wording in a room agreement that promises such a fee?
Why should "messing with a property's fixtures" be a bad thing? Heating and a/c controls were meant for customer use, as are light fixtures, curtains/blinds, coffee makers, hot tubs, etc. If the property wanted the refrigerator to run 24/7, no matter the impact on lifetime of the refrigerator, on their electric bill, or on the planet, then why do these refrigerators have temperature adjustment dials and on/off switches that are accessible to the hotel guest, just like the other appliances and fixtures? Why do they have plugs on cords, when they could be hard-wired into a circuit? If you're in a motel and the porch light is bothering you, you shut the curtains or switch off the light, right? The rooms I use warn me about pets, water usage, smoking, non-paying guests, etc. And there are usually warnings about using the door locks properly for my own safety (and to guard against liability on the part of the property owner.) If it is so harmful to turn a refrigerator off for a night or two, then why isn't there a warning of some kind right on the refrigerator door? My answer is that the property obviously expects customers to treat this appliance like any other room appliance. If they were routinely incurring damages that they could not afford, they would educate guests on the issue.
"If a piece of equipment is genuinely and causing an unusual racket, let the front desk staff know, and they'll handle it." Now that's some real faith in the front desk staff! They could call the maintenance person - who likely doesn't ever repair replace fridge compressors anyway as it requires special equipment... but they might be able to replace the fridge - IF a fresh one is on hand. But by 5 pm or so, he/she will have gone home for the day. And the front desk staff isn't qualified to work on or replace the things. They can maybe switch you to another room IF one is available, but they don't have a naughty/nice list for room refrigerators, so they have no clue if the switch will work for you. No one wants to play musical rooms if they don't need a fridge and they can just turn it off!