Please sign in to post.

Border control between Zurich/Switzerland- Ibiza/Spain?

Now I know this seems like a dumb question because I know both Switzerland and Spain are in Schengen, but yesterday I was left confused when I heard an acquaintance of mine say (because I plan going to Ibiza from Zurich in the summer) saying that when you flew back to CH from Spain, they asked for your papers/visa etc.
I wasn't able to clear out if he meant that when you check in they ask you or when about to board the plane (because I know they sometimes ask but it's not border control/immigration, just the flight staff asking) or if you go through actual border control.

It seems like an obvious answer, both countries are part of Schengen, but the acquaintance seemed certain in what he was saying which left me thinking. I just want to clear this doubt.

I have a Mexican passport and have no problem flying between Schengen area but I want to clear this up.

Thanks for your help

Posted by
12040 posts

Just to be clear, the Schengen Treaty removed routine border checks, but gives individual countries the right to perform targeted checks.

Posted by
2916 posts

the Schengen Treaty removed routine border checks, but gives individual countries the right to perform targeted checks.

And I believe that if a country declares a state of emergency (like France has done), they can have routine checks at specific borders.

Posted by
2092 posts

In other words, it would be good to have your passport easily acceptable to you while traveling between countries.

Posted by
1565 posts

At these troubled times, even for an internal flight you are likely to be requested to present ID multiple times: at check-in, at security control, at boarding. On a Schengen flight you skip the immigration stage, but you may still be requested to identify yourself.

Going from Zurich to Ibiza you will not be subject to immigration control, but in theory you could be subject to customs control as Switzerland is not part of EU - your luggage tags will not have green bands identifying luggage flying within EU and so being exempt from custom checks.

Posted by
8889 posts

The airline always requires ID, and that would normally be your passport which you would show at check-in and again before you board the plane. This is not border control, this is company or airport staff checking that your name matches the ticket.
Landing at Ibiza, as lachera says, from Zürich that is ex-EU, so you go through green "nothing to declare". If your friend went through blue EU exit with non-EU bags they would have been pulled over, or maybe they got the 1-in-100 random check in nothing-to-declare.
Customs can ask for ID (as can any policeman in the street), but you are only stamped in and stamped out when you enter or leave the Schengen Area.

A few hours ago I crossed from Switzerland to Germany and back again. Crossing into Germany there were 3 "Bundespolizei" (Federal Police) looking in the train window, presumably for illegal immigrants, but they didn't get on. Coming back, nothing.

Posted by
2916 posts

Yesterday someone on an RS forum said that recently when he flew from the US to Marseilles via Amsterdam he went through immigration in Amsterdam (as expected) and then again when he got off in Marseilles. I'm now curious what will happen next week when I fly Boston to Amsterdam to Lyon.

Posted by
8044 posts

Yeah but France of course is still under a state of emergency..
We were there flying in from Italy recently and went through a light passport control check.
The line went fast.

Posted by
11294 posts

As several people have posted above, being asked to show your passport (often required for ID, like when boarding a plane) is not the same as immigration/passport control. However, I've often seen people think they are the same. So, maybe your acquaintance mixed them up.

Posted by
231 posts

The Schengen Treaty only removed systematic border controls. It did not remove all checks. Immigration officers can still conduct spot checks whenever and wherever they see need for that. It's not unusual for them, for example, to meet Schengen flights at the end of the jet bridge on arrival, asking everyone to show their IDs/passports. This happened to me on a recent flight from Athens to Warsaw (both Greece and Poland are Schengen countries). Last year I was on a bus travelling from Warsaw to Lithuania (both in Schengen) and immigration officers got on the bus some 100km before the border to check everyone's papers.

Also, if you not an EU/EEA citizen and fly some budget airlines like Ryanair, you need to have your documents checked as per their T&Cs
https://www.ryanair.com/gb/en/useful-info/help-centre/faq-overview/passports-and-visas/im-a-non-eu-eea-passenger-do-I-need-extra-travel-document-visa-check

Posted by
4622 posts

I was the one who posted about AMS to MRS. My Schengen flight and a flight from Morocco were mingled, there was no spot anything, it was full immigration for everyone. There was no easy way for the French immigration guys to tell who came from which flight.