After doing some pretty extensive research, my husband has decided on Osprey's Porter 46. I, however, am still pretty undecided. I have heard some great things about Rick's bags - but also that they are not the most comfortable on the market. Can anyone share their thoughts about either of these brands? Or is there another brand that you prefer? Anything you can share will be so helpful. Thanks...
Posted by
Florida, USA
12172 posts
I found the discussion on www.onebag.com helpful. They don't sell bags, but talk about the features to look for and list some of their favorites.
Posted by
Newport Beach, CA, USA
769 posts
Kim - Ive always liked the Northface Packs (moslty day packs - and use the RS-bag for biger lugage). The NorthFace packs have great padding, good features, padded back with good breathable materials, and are usually waterproof. I havent tried their full size packs (40-60L or 3000-4000cu inch) but im sure they have all the great features and more of the day packs. Check out your REI. But as you may find other say - like - shoes - it is often a personal pref - so try it on if you can.
Posted by
Boston, MA, United States
1806 posts
I am not familiar with the RS or Osprey bags. I love my Eagle Creek backpack - they have a number of models to choose from and many are specifically designed for a woman's smaller frame/torso. They also come with a lifetime warranty and they'll repair or replace your bag free of charge (see Eagle Creek's website for details).
You need to try each pack on in the store (have the clerk add sand bags to the inside so you have an idea of how it feels with the weight - though even the same amount of weight will feel slightly different once you pack it for real as you will distribute the load more evenly). No matter what you choose, pack it the way you intend before you leave home and take a walk with it. If you can't walk at least 1 mile in it comfortably, it's either not the pack for you or you are trying to bring too much.
Posted by
Grapevine, TX, USA
875 posts
I, too, found the www.onebag.com site helpful and purchased a travel pack -- Voyageur from MEI. It is well built, lightweight, and does a good job of distributing the weight to one's hips rather than shoulders. Very well made -- no plastic zippers. Not as important, but the color choices are impressive.
Posted by
USR, NJ
277 posts
Having backpacked throughout Europe, I suggest the following: Go to your local sports shop, and try on the various backpacks sold. Since there are so many for different adventures, it's unwise to suggest any. Choose the backpack that fits your needs.