On your other thread you said you booked a quad room at Hotel des Nation St Germain.
JHK explained, as 75020 above did, that a quad room will not work for 5 people. JHK then suggested Hotel Excelsior Latin which does have room(s) for 5. You did not respond to her. You just kept posting a list of other hotels.
Gets difficult when you start two identical threads and you don’t acknowledge any of the information people have tried to give you.
I’m not familiar with your latest list so I can’t say which is best. I’d say any hotel in the 1st to 15th arrondissement that looks/sounds good to you, that has a room for 5, is worth booking. Seems like a hassle to move 5 people from one hotel to another for one night. Are you having no luck finding a room for 5 in one hotel for all your nights? If that’s the case, then take Norma’s advice, just book the one on your list whose photos/reviews look best to you.