Please sign in to post.

The Curious Case of the Confiscated Contraband: An Absolutely True Cautionary Tale

I arrived early for my interview with Homeland Security at the Global Entry Enrollment Center in Niagara Falls, New York.

I had applied for the interview via the U.S. Customs and Border Protection website because I wanted to get a Global Entry card for the Trusted Traveler Program and an in-person interview with Homeland Security was a required part of the application. My husband had also applied and had an interview a few weeks earlier. His interview had been easy and only took about ten minutes.

But mine was a little different.

A receptionist checked me in and after getting fingerprinted and photographed, a very serious looking young man wearing a crisp khaki uniform and official-looking Homeland Security badges called me from the waiting room and took me into an office where he sat across his desk from me, concentrated intently on his computer and asked me a series of questions. “Have you ever been arrested? Have you ever been deported? Have you ever entered the U.S. illegally? Have you ever been accused of drug smuggling? Have you ever engaged in terrorist activities?” I truthfully answered “No” to all of these questions.

Then he leaned forward, stared straight at me and asked if I had ever had anything confiscated from me at a border crossing. It seemed a little bit of an odd question but I couldn't think of anything so I said "No". I realized it was the wrong answer when he then asked me again, "Are you sure you’ve never had anything confiscated at a border crossing?" But I still couldn't think of anything. So, I said, “Yes, I’m sure.” Then, he asked a third time. “Are you absolutely sure that you’ve never had anything confiscated at a border crossing?” I was wracking my brain, but still couldn’t recall anything ever being confiscated from me at a border crossing so again I replied, “Yes, I’m sure.”

Then he told me, triumphantly, that he happened to know that 16 years earlier in Vancouver as I was crossing the border from Canada to the United States, I had had an orange taken away from me.

At that moment, I made the mistake of bursting out laughing. Because I was thinking guns, knives, drugs, bombs! My laughter set the border agent off on an angry tirade of, "You might laugh, but your failure to disclose the orange incident is very serious. This is a Trusted Traveler Program which means we need to be able to trust you."

He then launched into a speech about how bringing an orange from Canada into the United States could cause damage to our ecology, agriculture, and the VERY CULTURE of the United States. He talked about trustworthiness and failure to disclose important information. He warned me about loss of my passport, fines, arrest, and even imprisonment! I was confused and utterly speechless.

Then he sent me out to the waiting room while he did "further research" on the orange incident. Probably to check if I had also tried to bring in a banana. Or maybe even an apple. Possibly an entire fruit basket!

He left me waiting for about twenty minutes. While I waited, I thought about what the officer had said about possible arrest and imprisonment. I looked over at the receptionist and she seemed busy with something on her computer and wasn’t looking at me. I eyed the exit door and wondered if I should maybe just make a run for it. But the officer still had my passport, and besides, I had already paid the $100 non-refundable fee and I really wanted to get a Global Entry card. So, I got a grip and continued to wait.

Finally, the officer came out of his office, walked up to me in the waiting room and, without any explanation, handed me my passport with an approval letter, and said I was free to go. I wanted more information, so I asked him what his "research" had turned up, but he just mumbled that he didn't find any further information, walked back to his office and shut the door. I walked out a free woman and my Global Entry card arrived in the mail a few weeks later.

Posted by
7158 posts

Love it! Some people take their jobs very very seriously, to the point of being absolutely ridiculous. Glad you got your Global Entry.

Posted by
522 posts

Hmm...interesting how Vancouver, Washington has crossed the Canadian border.

Posted by
57 posts

When we joke about our "permanent record" in school, this is really our permanent record!

Posted by
165 posts

Possibly an entire fruit basket!

Bwahahahahahaha ... Just the laugh I needed today. What a world.

Posted by
535 posts

Ha! I once had an apple taken from me. I think I was returning from Paris via Charlotte. I said "Oops, I meant to eat that on the flight." He acted like it was no big deal and said "happens all the time."

I wondered if that incident would come up when I applied and interviewed for Global Entry. It didn't. Either it's not on my permanent record, or my GE interviewer didn't feel like indulging in a huge power trip that day.

Posted by
110 posts

When I had my interview over 12 years ago, they asked if I had ever been finger printed. Fortunately I remembered being finger printed my senior year of college 1980 when I interviewed with the National Security Agengy. When I told him, he said something like "that explains it" so I guess they still had some record of it.

Posted by
179 posts

I am glad you had a happy ending to your story! And now can look back with humor but it must have been really frightening at the time.
On my last trip transiting through Iceland there wasn't a lot of time between flights. The US bound plane had a below ground level really crowded waiting room for boarding and when it was my turn they asked me and another young man to come for extra screening.
I didn't think anything of it, it was a pleasant-seeming woman agent. I was put in a small room with a chair and she told me to take off my shoes - and then she took them away with her, along with my passport!
At that point I suddenly panicked (hence I know how you felt)- my rational self was certain all would be fine but the reality was she had my passport...and shoes? So I couldn't run away? Plus missing the plane.
She was gone for what seemed like ever, eventually reappeared, handed me my stuff and said I could go. I really wanted to know what the reason was, etc. but never found out.
So glad all's well and happy travels!

Posted by
5597 posts

Thanks for sharing- glad the records don't go much further back than that!

Posted by
913 posts

Ridiculous. Even on a lie detector test you would pass. If you honestly have no recall of it, the lie detector test would not find it a lie.

Posted by
14974 posts

I would never even crack a smile dealing with such people, let alone break out into a laughter. It's a matter of a strategy of attrition, which is how I see it. Crossing the Canadian border (only twice) into the US, I've never had anything confiscated or even had my carry-on opened and examined, the 2nd and last time was in 2017.

Your encounter makes me glad that I never applied for Global Entry and will not either, totally unnecessary, uninterested, and tedious.

Posted by
2688 posts

My mother is still annoyed about the oranges that were confiscated from her when we arrived in Victoria BC from Washington in 1983…coincidentally there were fruit vendors on the street and she was quite certain they were selling “her oranges”.

Posted by
996 posts

A very serious looking young man wearing a crisp khaki uniform and official-looking Homeland Security badges called me from the waiting room and took me into an office where he sat across his desk from me, concentrated intently on his computer and asked me a series of questions. “Have you ever been arrested? Have you ever been deported? Have you ever entered the U.S. illegally? Have you ever been accused of drug smuggling? Have you ever engaged in terrorist activities?” I truthfully answered “No” to all of these questions.

I could have had his twin brother for my Global Entry interview, except I gave him cold hard stares back in his effort to intimidate me into admitting something I KNEW I hadn't done. (I've got 2 decades of investment banking under my belt, I'm use to rude behavior.)

He asked me at least 3x if I'd ever been arrested. He also said something like, "That's not what I see here on the computer." (LIE) Then he rudely shoved back my passport with a global entry card. I think he was just angry he couldn't find anything in my record. Thank god we can now renew this online dealing with these bullies!

Posted by
4098 posts

Wow what a story! Hope to renew online before mine expires in a couple of years.

Posted by
1740 posts

Wow. I had a much more pleasant experience when I first applied for my Nexus card. I had to do an interview with Canadian border control and then, go to the US (next wicket over :D ) to do an interview with US border control.

Once, at security before a flight, I had something show up when they used a device on my carryon bag. Apparently, it showed traces of some kind of narcotic, which is really weird, because I don't do any kind of drugs and wasn't on any prescription meds that would qualify at the time. I said to my husband, "Cool! This is just like on Border Security!" (a tv show that is my secret vice). They checked out my bag, found nothing, and sent me on my way. They were nice about it.

Another time, I was carrying dried meat (biltong) back from Namibia. It was a gift from our guide. I knew it probably wouldn't be allowed (because I watch Border Security g). Anyway, it WAS confiscated, but nobody was unpleasant about it, because I had been honest and declared it.

The only times I've had truly unpleasant experiences were at Heathrow and Munich airports.

But I love my Nexus card, and would definitely put up with some crankiness for it, if I had to.

Posted by
1299 posts

Living in Seattle, I have crossed the BC border many times. As I was reading your story where he asked you "are you sure", I tried to remember whether I ever have had something confiscated. I truly can't. That's not saying I have never had it happen, I truly can't remember. It's such a a common thing at that border, I've crossed that border with so many different people, etc. My husband had to give up a meat sandwich once, but it seems funny to think that is on his permanent record

Posted by
1568 posts

My late mother, always kind of a smarty-pants, made some kind of a sarcastic joke about bombs in front of the ticket agent at the airport and was not allowed on her plane. This was long before the September 11th terrorist attacks. She had a permanent mark on her record such that, well into her frail nineties and in a wheelchair, she was always stopped and searched and questioned at airports in the US.

Strangely (or perhaps not so strangely if my taste in men was influenced by my family of origin's sense of humor) my future husband also made such a joke at the airport when we were in college, was not allowed on the plane, and to this day still fools around about repeating a joke like that while in airports and has to be shushed. You never know who might be listening! However, what he said must have been not as bad as what my mother said because he is not stopped and searched.

Posted by
1583 posts

My experience with getting a Nexus card back when you could at Boeing Field was much like BB's. Very pleasant. Very nice. Even smiling. No aggressive questioning. Both the Canadian and US officers seemed to treat their occupations as a public service, not as paramilitary members.

Posted by
17 posts

An acquaintance told me that she answered "no" to the confiscation question and was reminded of some sausage that she'd had to surrender some years earlier, so when I was asked that question at my interview I knew to cop to the apple I'd once forgotten in my carry-on. A couple of years later, my husband forgot about the sandwich he'd neglected to eat before we re-entered the U.S. and we were lectured severely and at length by the customs agent. We were told that if it happened again our Trusted Traveler status would be revoked, zero tolerance. We learned our lesson!

Posted by
272 posts

Personally, if I was doing the job for real, and had competent people, I would train people to question like this to get the indignation reaction back. One of the better indications that the person is legit if the interviewer is good enough to pick up on the emotional states. A sort of reverse Hanlon's razor.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor

Of course, I doubt that's what's happening here. :)

Posted by
21139 posts

A friend on a group ski trip had an identical experience crossing the border on a bus on the way between Whistler and Seattle. Other than a lecture and confiscation of the offending orange, no consequences. But my question is; the orange had a "Sunkist" stamp on it and I wondered where in Canada do they grow Sunkist oranges?

Posted by
8963 posts

Forgive me if I am less sympathetic than most responders here. What RobertH said is right. If you've ever been involved in security type situations, you know that you ask questions to make the respondent uncomfortable, and see if they lie, or get nervous or panic. They already know the answers beofre you show up, they just want to see your reaction. People who lie about little things are more likely to lie about other things as well. In this case, the reaction of not taking it seriously was what made it tense.

I have an entomologist friend who does the airport agriculture inspections. His stories of what people try to smuggle in, and lie about are amazing. A daily occurrence. And while we might think it's trivial and amusing to have food confiscated, there is a reason for those rules, and they take their job seriously. I know someone who got caught accidentally bringing a plum in, and chuckled about it thinking it wasn't a big deal. They took her aside and went through all her luggage piece by piece. It's the reaction to being caught that decides how seriously to take it. When you read about someone being fined $xxxx for a piece of fruit, it's always the attitude of the person that escalates things, not just the fruit.

The CBP officer in this case, has to make judgments and yes they're subject to the same range of human emotions and indignation at not being taken seriously that a traffic cop does.

Posted by
14974 posts

One has to adopt a certain demeaner and attitude when dealing with these types and such bureaucracy and "officialdom".

Prepare to be humorless and perfunctory. You can be certain that "their" attempts at using humor with you by creating a frivolous moment are insincere., ie, just bait. Luckily, I have never encountered such experiences as described above.

Posted by
272 posts

"Prepare to be humorless and perfunctory."

That'll work. It's kind of the "default" for experienced people. "Indignation" is good too, at least for less experienced travelers, the legitimate ones. Many will work, and what they're looking for. At least if you're not getting the jerks.

My only trip, before Covid, was a couple of RS tours and I came back to Portland from Amsterdam. It was a very long day, I'm old, and wasn't in a great mood as I came through at Portland. He said something inane like "Is there anything else you want to say" and I just glared at him and said "no".

That worked too.

Posted by
11872 posts

Then he leaned forward, stared straight at me and asked if I had ever had anything confiscated from me at a border crossing. It seemed a little bit of an odd question but I couldn't think of anything so I said "No". I realized it was the wrong answer when he then asked me again,

That sure seems to have been the point that "Not that I can recall" would have been the better answer.

Posted by
30 posts

Wow, we did our interview at the salt Lake City Terminal in 2021 and had a great time blabbing with the officer. It was short and pleasant. SLC seems like a more casual Terminal overall. We like layovers there and even have a favorite restaurant.

Posted by
16269 posts

I am amazed at just how much information they have.

When I had to do a GE renewal interview, the agent doing it asked me about my trip to the "Channel Islands." He had never heard of them. He thought they were in Asia.

But then I realized.....I visited the Channel Islands from England a few years earlier. London to Jersey. There was no border check. The only record is the flight.

My experience getting GE was over 10 years ago. Initial interview at IAD. They only had 15 minutes for each person. I was asked a few questions, fingerprinted, photographed and warned that any legal infraction, including DUI--he emphasized this--could mean the loss of my Trusted Traveler status. The person interviewing me was a CPB agent in their normal dark blue uniform.

I did my renewal interview, mentioned above, using the "interview on arrival" program at JFK. A few questions about where I'd been since getting GE status and that was it.

My most recent renewal was done online and I didn't need to do an interview. However, it took 11 months to get my approval.