For comparison - I’ve traveled with Road Scholar (3), Gate 1 (2), Smartours (2), Odysseys Unlimited (1), and Rick Steves (1).
OAT is tied at the top of my list with Road Scholar. Why?
1) Small group size - there were 15 of us, with the max size being 16. We traveled around on a full size bus.
2) Itinerary - we stayed 3 nights most places. The itinerary was quite fluid - something I’ve never seen before on a tour. If one day had bad weather and the next day looked good, our Trip Leader would swap sites and move things around. As we traveled, she checked local event calendars and added in fun options many days. For example, in Helsinki, she saw a free evening concert at Church in the Rock, and offered to head over there with anyone who wanted to go. This fluidity made the trip even better.
3) Guide - One of the top two guides we’ve ever had. Friendly, funny, organized, and always planning, thinking, working to make the trip better. She clearly has a lot of freedom from the home OAT office to adjust, adapt etc.
4) Hotels - the first tour I’ve EVER taken with all solid hotels. Usually there’s at least one bad one. But not this tour. All nice 4 star hotels, good rooms, and excellent locations. I have no negative comments or suggestions for improvement on the hotels used.
5) Tour mates - luck of the draw, I know, but these people LOVE OAT. There are people on this tour who have done over 20 OAT tours and they rave to us about them.
6) Local guides - OAT provides more than I’ve had on any other tour. They were uniformly excellent - good English speakers and interesting.
7) Local speakers/lecturers - I loved these parts of the tour. They were all PhD holders in their topics and discussed controversial political/social things with us and let us ask all the questions we wanted. My tour mates asked great questions and I ended up learning a ton.
8) Meals - meals were smaller and simpler than on other tours and I loved that. On my last Odysseys Unlimited tour one evening, the appetizer was chicken nuggets and fries and then the main meal was a duck breast. Really. OAT often has lunch with just a bowl of nice soup, bread, coffee and a light pastry.
Would I travel with OAT again? Absolutely. In fact, I’m thinking of changing my fall 2024 from a Gate 1 to an OAT.