I am starting with the planning context and itinerary here, then due to character limitations, subsequent posts for the overview and take aways. And finally, the nitty gritty daily details on itinerary including sights, accommodations and observations, segregated by date.
Please pardon misspellings (including the absence of proper Icelandic letters) and typos! I'm also not on the forums regularly, so feel free to send me a message with any specific questions.
Planning Context:
2 adults, 2 teens. This trip was our first time in Iceland. The plan started off as a few overnights to recover from jet lag on route to Europe. It turned into a quest to the North! This made the trip planning challenging (the best and most economical lodging does book up quickly!) and I was definitely too ambitious.
However, although I would do several things differently, I don't regret minimizing our time in the Golden Circle, skipping Reykjavik and speeding through the South/Southwest. The way it worked out, all of that is easily doable on a second, shorter trip (I'll leave that for my kids!).
We packed light, but due to our subsequent travels to different climates and planning for souvenirs, we checked two suitcases. We stayed at Aurora Hotel at the airport the night before our departure to Europe and the night after our return from Europe (before returning to the States), and therefore was able to leave our two suitcases in storage there.
TINERARY (10 nights):
Golden Circle - 1 night
Hvammstangi - 1 night
Siglufjordur - 1 night
Myvatn - 1 night
Húsavík - 2 nights
Wilderness Center (Egilstaðir area) - 1 night
Vatnajökull National Park area - 1 night
Vestmannaeyjabær - 1 night
Keflavik (Aurora Hotel) - 1 night
LISTS:
Favorite Sights / Experiences:
Gullfoss
Thingvellir
Settlement Center
Glaumbaer Farm
Hvitserkur
Siglufjordur
Herring Era Museum
Whale Watching Excursion in Húsavík
Studlagil Canyon
Seydisfjordur
Petra's Stone Collection
Diamond Beach
Skaftafellsjokull gongueid
Seljalandsfoss
Vestmannaeyjar (Risk Steves walking tour)
Puffin Lookout
Eldheimar
Favorite Lodging: Hotel Siglunes in Siglufjordur
Honorable Mentions:
Gamli Skolinn Húsavík
The New Post Office in Vestmannaeyjar
Favorite Restaurants:
Sjavarborg in Hvammstangi
Siglunes in Siglufjordur
Gamli Baukur in Húsavík (ate there twice!)
Wilderness Center in Egilstadir
Gott in Vestmannaeyjar (ate there twice!)
Thermal Pools we Visited (can't pick absolute favorite, all good for different reasons):
Laugarvatn Fontana
Myvatn
Geo Sea