I will try to keep this concise (ha!) with an eye towards practical advice for anyone considering Rome. But it's always important to explain where you're coming from and what your travel style is, so here goes:
Early 40s couple, both with a shared interest in ancient Western history (him especially) and medieval and renaissance art (her especially), "museum people", foodies, beer nerds, winos, experienced travelers as expats in Europe, FINALLY got around to our first trip to Rome after a brief trip to Venice a couple years ago and Naples earlier this year. We were supposed to go to Israel for this trip and reconsidered based on the advice of people on this forum, will be planning Israel for spring, hopefully. Dates were Oct 15-21 2019.
I threw myself into planning early on, then got really busy and didn't really "finish" planning until the night before. We had booked a flat in Trastevere just across from the Punto Sisto. Our "plan" was to splurge a little on this lovely flat ("Unforgettable Trastevere" on Booking.com) to use as a siesta spot but the reality of how large Rome is meant we never, ever went back to our flat in the afternoons for rest as we'd planned - just too time consuming. (Maybe an option for early risers, which we are not). Great location, though, the neighborhood is crazy at night (which we like) but the flat is amazingly quiet with an inner courtyard (which we also like).
Day 1: Mostly involved our flight from Germany, taking the normal train from the airport to the Trastevere station then the metro. Our check-in was simple (communicating via WhatsApp with the host) if not overly-friendly. The owners have the flat next door, and apparently my husband heard them fighting one morning. We had a couple odd run-ins with them (I answered a buzzer for a charity and the owner lady came out startled, another time there was water from some apartment rushing down below and the owner man entered without much warning but was in and out in 10 seconds so, no huge deal). Still, at about $135/night the flat was really lovely and uniquely decorated, and if that's what you'd normally spend on a hotel, I'd consider staying in a flat. I made eggs and salami one morning for breakfast, we ate the generous pastries supplied by the owners, and liked having cold fizzy water and beverages and snacks available to us at all times.
We skipped past a Conad store to get groceries at a Carrefour instead, which was a mistake I later realized - the Conad looked like a department store but of course, the very good grocery store was in the basement. (9 years in Europe, you think I would have figured this out by now!) By the time we'd settled in and stocked up, it was time for our short walk across the Tiber to our 5:00 p.m. wine tasting and dinner experience at Rimessa Roscioli. It didn't shake out like I'd hoped...
cont...