Please sign in to post.

Transat vs Air Canada: Your choice ?

Hi !
Family Flight to Paris and return from Lyon

Option 1 Transat:

Yul-CDG 21:50 departure .
2x2 seats at the back of a330 (180$ more) .
LYS-Yul 13:00 (let the systme select our seats for free) on a 330-300 (9 seats wide)
3160$

Option 2 AIr Canada
YUL-CDG 20:50 departure

Select seats for free (since we are with kids) seats. 8 seats wide on the A330. So 2x2 seats everywhere in the plane.
LYS-YUL 10;30 (early !!) on the same A330
3410 $

Advantage of option 1: Less expensive (250$), better departure time from Lyon
Advantage of option 2: Air Canada ? 2x2 seat on both flights.

Thanks !

Posted by
7834 posts

If you are not on a budget spend more. Air Transat does not have any alliances code shares with other airlines like Air Canada does as part of the Star Alliance. In case a flight is canceled Air Canada as part of the Star Alliance would have more options to get you there or back home sooner than later

I would only book Air Transat traveling solo or with another person that would not be inconvenienced by a flight being canceled while in Europe on the way back.

Posted by
4573 posts

I would use AC for seat selection. As I don't fly with family, I don't know whether AC is like some US airlines that don't always seat parties together if uou leave it up to them. I wouldn't want to risk that. But either one, if this is some months out, airplane may change meaning a different config. If that happens, with confirmed seats you can make changes to suit.

Posted by
10 posts

I flew a family of four from Calgary to Dublin this summer on Transat. They were clean, cheap, on time, and all an airline should be. Granted, there are few safeguards if something goes wrong. but I believe that is also true with most other airlines too.

Posted by
8293 posts

I do like that AirTransat lands at Terminal 3, which is so much easier to navigate than Term. 2. We usually take Bus 351 into Paris and its stop is about a 3 minute walk after we exit the terminal.

Posted by
2299 posts

hey hey bucephale
sent you a private message (PM) about annecy area. upper right hand corner under account may say unread message.
aloha

Posted by
32201 posts

bucephale,

I've used both and my choice is usually Air Canada for several reasons....

  • they have more frequent service out of this area and better integration between the regional AC Express flights and the longer AC flights to Europe.
  • as mentioned earlier, Air Canada has better connections via their Star Alliance partner airlines. That means I can check my luggage once at my home airport and then not have to retrieve it until the final destination.
  • Air Canada offers many more flights than does Air Transat, which only operates to some destinations once per week.
  • I can accumulate AeroPlan points with AC flights.
  • the prices usually aren't much different as they both have to pay similar fuel, staff, airport fees and aircraft operation costs. As I recall, the Air Transat fleet is a bit older so won't be quite as fuel efficient (higher costs?).
  • They're now part of the same company (final ruling on that in May 2020), so choose the one that has the best price and fits your schedule best. It looks like you're based out of Montreal, so won't have to take any connecting flights.
Posted by
360 posts

Thanks for all those answers !

All the advantages written in the last before is not something important for us. We dont have connecting flights !

Still debating.
450$ more for AIr Canada if I let Transat select our seats for free
130$ more for Air Canada if we select seat (2x2) on transat