Please sign in to post.

Never rent through Discover Cars

Never, ever use Discover Cars for your holiday rental! They are a car rental broker, an online comparison/aggregator platform connecting you with car rental agencies, which seems like a good way to filter and compare prices – until something goes wrong.

I booked a car through Discover Cars for 11 days in Puglia, Italy, with the rental company Locauto. I paid Discover Cars directly for the rental price, and I was directed to pay the “additional driver” price of $179 CDN at the Locauto desk. A very basic insurance is included for all rental cars in Italy, but I wanted to be properly covered. Discover Cars advertised a car insurance price of $21.68/day CDN. Since I’m over 65, my credit card doesn’t cover car insurance, so I figured I’d pay the insurance at the Locauto desk when I arrived. And this is where everything went wrong…

At the desk in the Bari Airport, Locauto informed me that the cost of the cheapest insurance available through them was 512 Euros – over $400 CDN more than Discovery Car’s advertised price. When I objected to the Locauto price, they said I’d have to take it up with Discover Cars. After a very long flight, I felt pressured to pay the insurance because I wanted to be properly insured and did not feel I had an alternative.

When I contacted Discover Cars through their online portal, they said I’d have to take it up with Locauto. Both agencies pointed fingers at each other, basically saying: so sorry, but not my problem. When I asked Discover Cars’ ingratiating virtual agent (AI) to put me in touch with a supervisor, Charlie AI thought this was a good idea – but I never heard from a supervisor. And I never heard back from Locauto.

The lesson: once they have your money in their pockets, they don’t want to talk to you. So, from now on, I will only deal directly with a car rental agency – no intermediaries. Avoid Discover Cars!

Posted by
3728 posts

I think you may have experienced the difference between a consolidators insurance and the rental car company’s. I had reserved a car in my husbands name but using a credit card in my name a few years ago. That would work for payment but not insurance. By the time I figured it out, the rental car cost had climbed. So I bought insurance from AutoEurope for a fairly nominal sum which was a lot less than what Avis offered us when we picked up the car.

Posted by
13686 posts

Since I’m over 65, my credit card doesn’t cover car insurance, so I figured I’d pay the insurance at the Locauto desk when I arrived.

What credit card do you have? I have two credit cards that cover car insurance, and there is no age limitation in there as long as the rental company is okay with it. I used my Chase Sapphire Preferred card to pay for car rental insurance about a year or two agao (I was 70 at the time) and was reimbursed when I got a small ding in the car. There was never any mention of age in there.

Posted by
9458 posts

Sorry to hear about your experience with Discover Cars. Insurance seems to be a major issue with car rental. We usually book directly with the rental company, but have used Discover Cars three times, when their prices were far lower than any others.

A year ago, it was picking up in Naples and returning in Bari, Puglia. The off-brand company that Discover Cars found - we chose their third-cheapest company, as the cheapest two had horrible reviews - was a bit sketchy, but in the end, worked. I won’t say we’d never use Discover Cars again, but I’d look elsewhere first. And, for insurance, our Chase VISA makes the big difference in all of those choices.

Our Chase card is a different one than Mardee’s, and we are both over 65, but are American, and the card provides outstanding insurance waiver coverage. We needed that in Norway 3 years ago. Our VISA has meant not having to take insurance from a rental company, whether referred by Discover Cars or anyone else.