I’m an aisle seat person, but my husband wants a window seat, specifically for the views through the window. No window, no “window seat,” no question.
The only type of seat that a passenger won’t expect to have some bonus desired attribute is a middle seat, and none of those are identified as anything other than “middle.” With so many airlines now charging extra for specific seats, being accurate as to a seat’s specifics is necessary.
The theater analogy is accurate. We’ve just booked seats for several performances coming up in London this fall, and were glad to know what seats had obstructed views, or limited knee room, or a high wall in front of seats, or stools instead of chairs, etc. The discounted prices weren’t enough to sway getting crappy seats, but the theater providing the information was essential to having satisfied customers. Describing a seat inaccurately amounts to false advertising, and some of that money obtained through misidentification is going back to wronged customers. Take in less money beforehand, or pay out more later - sounds very fair.