The split fares quoted above are not correct fares for the OP's day of travel. I have had the OP's original post bookmarked and on follow up for several weeks, because I follow up cases to their conclusion.
The fare the OP is quoting are 'open singles' allowing her to travel on any train that day on the line of route, not restricting her to that particular train which is booked- which is the most expensive option available (other than the via Birmingham route).
What worries me more is that the OP is travelling the North Wales coast line on a Bank Holiday Saturday, with the first two legs Conwy to Chester and Chester to Crewe being on TfW's 2 car trains, on which no seats can be reserved, at a time of day when they could be very easy.
I, personally, would have opted to travel ex Llandudno Junction (with or without the local train across the bridge from Conwy to LJ) on the earlier through Avanti 5 car service from LJ to Euston, which almost certainly attaches to a second 5 car unit at Chester to form a 10 car train forward.
That train is much more likely to give a comfortable journey.
Some people also like the comfort of a through ticket rather than fretting about connections between separate tickets -however, for completeness, the correct split in the example quoted above is £15.90 + £50.10 + £17.50, for that particular day and combination of journeys.
On the earlier through train the same split would be £39.60 + £44.80 + £17.50, but of course you could end up having to change seats at Crewe (even having to switch between the 2x 5 car units- which has to be done on the platform as you can't walk inside the train between the units), booking it that way- as the system may allot you different seats for the 2 parts of the through journey.
My view is that the OP has had a lot of advice on this journey- if she wishes to book unrestricted through tickets that is her prerogative.
And yes I do know about the unreserved coach on the train, but joining the train well into its journey that might be full at LJ- unlikely but possible.
There are plus and minus points to either approach.