Please sign in to post.

Minimum train connection/transfer times

I've read about how prompt the trains are in Germany and just the opposite in Italy. In our upcoming trip, the majority of our train transfers will be in Germany with a few also in Switzerland, France, and Italy. I'm in need of some experienced opinions of how short is too short for transfer times between trains in different countries.

For instance, some of the connections that fit our planned schedule are as short as 5 minutes, in Germany. Is this too short a time or is it reasonable? If too short, what might be reasonable minimum transfer time? What about Switzerland, France, and Italy?

This would be for non-metropolitan stations (2-8 platforms, all next to one another) and so the driving factor would be the on-time performance of the train we are transferring from plus the time it would take us to figure out which platform and car to transfer to (I'm trying to find station maps where available on the net).

There are just the two of us, carry-on luggage only, fit enough to hustle from one platform to another, no children in tow.

Thanks in advance for your help. With your advice I will finally be ready to start finalizing our month-long schedule.

Posted by
12040 posts

Except for a few very large multi-level stations (Rotterdam, Antwerpen, Warsaw), 5 minutes is usually enough time to transfer, at least in Germany. In a few of the stations where the trains back into the station, you may have to hurry if you sit on the far side of the train.

Posted by
19274 posts

You can find a layout of any DB or S-Bahn station in Bavaria here. Plans for stations in the Frankfurt metro area, RMV, are here.

Most station have a 1,2-3,4-5,6-7, etc layout, with, for instance, tracks 2 and 3 sharing a platform. There are some notable exceptions.

In most cases, for the Bahn, if they show a connection with 5 minutes to change trains, it will be enough time. Usually, if one train is a little late, the other train will wait for it. A lot of lines have a train an hour, so it your train is very late, and you miss your connection, there will be a following train pretty soon.

Most importantly, know when you are coming to your transfer station (time or previous station). Just before you arrive, leave your seat and be at the end of the car, with your luggage, by the door when the train stops. Proceed directly to the next train. Others will be making the same change; stay with the herd. The conductor will be watching and will not release the train while people are boarding.

Posted by
36 posts

Tom and Lee,

Thanks for the advice. This really does help me relax a little since there are a few short connections in my itinerary. I do plan to verify later train schedules in case of itinerary malfunction, enroute.

I also kept digging in the archives and just found some of your similar advice to someone a few months ago:
http://www.ricksteves.com/graffiti/helpline/index.cfm?topic=47204

My apologies for your duplicated efforts and thanks again for your help.

Posted by
1530 posts

The ONLY train station we ever had an issue of almost missing our connection was in Basel. There half of the station is in Switzerland and half in France with 2 distinct sections and very little signage.

We frequently had connections of 3 to 5 minutes in Germany and never had a problem.

Posted by
1158 posts

For germany sounds fine, but for Italy no.
My train from Florence to Rome arrived 30 minutes late.

Posted by
33852 posts

Most German and Austrian trains of IC or higher service will have little description sheets available showing the path the train takes and giving platforms for your train and many connections.

In Germany, Austria, Switzerland, and the Netherlands the connections are often just across the platforms, and well timed.

I wouldn't say the same for France, Italy, or Belgium.

If you check your connections on the national railway site for the country involved; for example www.sbb.ch for Switzerland, you will often find the platforms of the connection will be given.

Posted by
19274 posts

On the German Rail website, if you find a connection, there will be a '>' symbol in a box on the LH side of the connection. Clicking it will expand the connection to show all the trains for that connection, including the arrival and departure times. In Germany the track numbers will also be shown. Farther down the page, click on "At the train station". For major stations it will also give you a track plan for that station.