Please sign in to post.

Marais or 7th near Eiffel- help needed on where to stay?

My family of four is planning a trip to France this fall - October. I've got most of the critical elements planned - flights, hotels, etc. Except Paris -we'll be there for four days only. I have searched high and low and found two apartments which we are considering. One is in the Marais and the other is in the 7th.

The one in the Marais is about two blocks further from the Seine than the Hotel De Ville, along ave de la Brettonerrie. The one in the 7th is one street away from the park at the base of the Eiffel Tower, near ave de la Bourdonais/rue Moussuey.

As we've never been to Paris - we'll do the typical sightseeing stuff - Louvre, Orsay, Arc, Eiffel, Notre Dame, etc. We don't mind a lot of walking, and I can probably figure out the metro - plus there are always cabs. My only consideration is that October will most likely be cold, and could be rainy - so that may become a factor if we plan to walk the entire city.

I was trying to find something that didn't make me feel like I was home or in a large city, I wanted something that made me feel as if I was in France (if that makes any sense).

My dilema is this - when I google the streets around both, I get mixed feelings. The Marais seems crowded, but appears to have much to offer in line of shopping and eating. The pics almost made me feel as if the cruch of folks on the streets were all tourists, but that could just be me. When I google the one in the 7th, it looked like a lovely spot but not so 'French', plus I didn't see many pastry shops, restaurants, shopping, etc. In these pics, I did see many tourist buses, so that gave me pause.

Can anyone offer any personal opinions, suggestions - on which of these two you think would be a better choice for our first visit to Paris?

I would apprecaite any insight anyone would have.

Posted by
290 posts

My vote is the Marais. That is usually my home base in Paris. To put it very simple, if I wanted to be surrounded by Americans in a particular neighborhood then I would visit an USA city. The 7th has too many Rick Nicks. I like being completely surrounded by locals of any country I visit & take a night class to learn the language basics before going. You can say I'm a complete travel nut & invest a minimum of 60 hours research for each trip. Before I even get to a major city, I use a route planner to know how exactly to get to my temporary diggs & already have a pretty good working knowledge of what metro & bus lines I need to take from my temporary diggs to all the sights I want to see. Many times I just end up walking. Marais is very good for that. Notre Dame & Pompedou are a short walk from the Hotel De Ville area. Some of the best food and drinking establishments are in that area. The RS books get completely studied AT HOME, and then kept in my daybag out of sight except when I need it. So many times I see folks with their noses buried in the books while walking around and feel sorry they are missing out on so much of what's going around them. And it makes me wonder how many have accidents from not paying attention to what's going on around them. Not to mention being pickpocketed. Nothing screams "rob me" more than someone with their nose buried in a book walking around, especially if its a travel guidebook. My suggestion is to pick up a pocket sized fold out laminated Paris map from your local bookstore. They all have mini metro maps on them. Note on the map all places you want to see. Keep a palm sized note pad & pen in your pocket with all places day by day you want to see with metro line and stop next to it with opening hours. This is more handy than trying to flip through a guidebook. I tended to use the guidebook inside the museums and galleries mostly since all other info is on my notepad.

Posted by
283 posts

I have stayed in both locations. From the 7th, you will need to take the Metro more than the Marais, which is in walking distance (long walks) of most of the central sights: Notre Dame, San Chapelle, Isle St Louis, etc. We even walked from the Louvre back to our apartment--a very long walk but a wonderful time.

The Marais also has the standard line going right through the heart of Paris, so fewer train changes for the major sights. BUT it can be very crowded.

The 7th is also Rick Steves country. You will see lots of Americans in both spots, but the 7th is flooded with us, and it is a little overwhelming.

Both are good, but I would choose the location closest to the Metro. Cost on the Metro is always the same, but the walk home from the Metro is a big consideration at the end of a long day of sights.

Posted by
360 posts

I've never stayed the Marais but have stayed many times in the 7th. Obviously, it's my personal choice. The area is very French - very Parisian. I've walked along the ave Bourdonnais at night looking up into the lighted windows wondering what it would be like to live there. There are many cafes & patisseries in the 7th but maybe not on Ave Bourd itself. You'll have to walk a few block to find shopping. I couldn't find the cross street you mentioned on my map, so not sure exactly where you'll be. If it Monttessuy it's close to the Seine & close to the Eiffel Tower which accounts for the buses. You might ask them about noise from the buses but my quess is that the windows will shut it out. You will be close to several attractions - the Eiffel Tower (be sure to see the light show at the top of the hour, Les Invalides (my favorite place in Paris), & the Rodin museum. Plus the Branly musee is very close to you, but it's not one I like. If you want to be close to night life, the 7th is not a good choice. If you want peacefull streets at night, it is. There's been lots written on this site about the 2 areas & if you look them up, you'll find that people either like the areas or they don't.

Posted by
590 posts

I have stayed in the Marais district and loved it. It was close to the metro, Notre Dame and great restaurants. Every restaurant that we ate at we were surrounded by locals. I saw fewer tourists in this area compared to the other districts in the "tourist" parts of Paris. I also felt very safe walking around at night as there were lots of people around.

Posted by
335 posts

A year ago last September, a friend and I rented an apartment on the corner of de la Brettoneire and Rue Temple. It was hot so we had to open the windows for a breeze and IT WAS NOISY, with traffic during the day and bar hoppers until the early am. So ask if your apt is on a noisy street (or hopefully facing a courtyard). This coming June we're staying in the 7th on Passage de l'Union which looks like a side street on the map (and thus hopefully a little quieter!) Wherever you end, just take earplugs and hope for the best.

Posted by
118 posts

The nice thing about your choice is that which ever area you decide to stay, that will be your favorite. My wife and I have stayed in both several times and enjoyed every minute in each place. The one small advantage the Marais might have is that it is easy to walk to several great sights.
We love Paris in October. Sometimes it rains but that's a good time for a museum. For the last several Octobers when we have been in Paris, the weather has been nice, cool nights and warm, sunny days. Have a great time.

Posted by
3313 posts

The 7th is home to many government agencies, meaning that you end up walking long blocks with grim cement exteriors. The shopping streets are spread out. The Marais has much more variety and is closer to more diverse neighborhoods.

Posted by
2030 posts

The Marais is in the center of the action to be sure, and may be more noisy than the 7th, but I would stay here, particularly if you have children, of whatever age. Much more to do, much more interesting, with an old time Parisian ambiance. Great area to just walk around. Of course the 7th is near the Eiffel Tower and you obviously want to see that, but you don't have to stay near it. And I have been to Paris in Oct. several times and the weather was always mild and nice (though you can't tell what it will be like with the crazy weather patterns we are having), it should be fabulous.

Posted by
262 posts

Cynthia,
I vote Marais! Have stayed in both areas, as I like to try different arroundisments (areas) when I go to Paris. The Marais is close to the Seine, the Louvre, Notre Dame and the Pompidou Center. The Orsay is a nice walk but not too far if you like to walking. I say the Eiffel Tower is one of the furthest attraction from the Marais as well the Champs Elysees and the Arc.
I don't think it's any more crowded than any other area. I don't think either is a bad choice, really.
Enjoy your trip. You are going at one of the very best times of the year.

Happy Travels,
Debi

Posted by
359 posts

Cynthia; what's the age range of your family? Could make a difference in opinions from the posters. I've stayed in both but am a baby boomer so what appeals to you may not for me. I prefer the 7th and confess do not recall seeing the 'grey facades of government buildings' (or something similar) as alluded to by one poster.

Posted by
14 posts

Thank you everyone for your commments/input. Even though I understand this is all personal opinion - to get input from others who have actually been to these locations does help me understand the areas a bit better when I get each person's perspective.

In an answer to a couple questions: My kids will be 12 and 13 when we go, great travelers, well-behaved and love to shop and explore, and they even enjoy museums - on a more limited scale, of course. We love to walk (ok, so I love to walk and drag my family) - we've been known to walk over 10 miles just for exercise around our home. When we went on our last trip, I wore a pedometer just to see how much we walked, and it averaged out to 13 miles per day. I am hoping the weather holds out for us so we can walk the entire trip - depending on time. If we need to metro due to limited time, then so be it.

We've been to Europe a few times, always in October due to my husbands busy schedule. Though it's not the opimimum time to go for some places, it has proven to be a great time for us - less tourism, etc. We generally luck out and get decent weather (except the year we went to the Netherlands - it was very wet and cold, but added to the experience).

On another site, I've communicated with a poster who is from the US and lives in the Marais. He walked by the apt. in that area and thought it was a good location - so that is very helpful.

I don't know if it will matter - but we will be there during the week, so the noisy streets may be less of an issue as it is during the work week?

Again - thanks to all for your thoughts, it honestly does help me quite a bit.

Happy Travels