Good grub in Edinburgh

Hi Posters--very excited to be traveling to Edinburgh this May...can anyone recommend good restaurants and pubs to hit during our trip?

Posted by Monte
Genesee, ID
1708 posts

The Rough Guide To Scotland has an excellent list of places to eat and drink. If you are a reader Alexander McCall-Smith's Scotland Street series can give you the good places to eat, drink, and shop. Ian Rankin's John Rebus novels aare another source of local Edinburgh lore.

Posted by Ken
Vernon, Canada
21463 posts

Sarah, Depending on what type of "grub" you're interested in, the Pubs are good for simple meals (along with a pint of course). A couple of Pubs you could consider are Sandy Bell's or Greyfriars Bobby's. I had a really nice dinner at an Italian restaurant in Edinburgh. As I recall it wasn't too far off the Royal Mile. It might have been Ciao Roma but I'd have to check my notes. Happy travels!

Posted by Gretchen
Andover, MA, USA
427 posts

Hi Sarah, For something slightly upscale, but not really, you could try: Howie's restaurants. There are two locations in Edinburgh. The one I visited is the Waterloo location, kitty-corner across the street from the Balmoral Hotel (near the base of Calton Hill). Enjoy your vacation.

Posted by Mike
121 posts

Sarah Burger King downtown-not kidding. There is a reason why the Scots are the heaviest drinkers in the world. I do think there are some nice restaurants for seafood in Leith-but really don`t remember anything else as passable when we were there 4 years ago. Hopefully its gotten better-but definitely be prepared to pay for better quality food. Alcohol is reasonable though. Mike DC

Posted by Pamela
New York City, NY, USA
4211 posts

Try the Mussel Inn in New Town for sea food. It's great. If you want more upscale, Creelers on The Royal Mile is excellent as Fisher's again in New Town. They served an Arbroath Smokie that was fantastic! More sea food at The Shore in Leith if you're down that way. Also, Edinburgh has lots of international food--Italian, Turkish, Spanish tapas etc. And of course, curry. I'd ask at your B&B for local recs. I haven't eaten at Sandy's Bells, but I've enjoyed an ale or two there and they have live music. Here's a link to the NY Times restaurant listings. It's got all the expensive ones too. Someday I'm eating at the Witchery. ; )

Posted by Keith
United Kingdom
893 posts

Edinburgh might not be the culinary paradise that Finkle clearly is, but I think you can do better than Burger King. When I'm going to a place I don't know, I use to get some recommendations. I have though been to the pub Ken and Pamela mention and it is fine. Incidentally, the Scots are not the world's heaviest drinkers, they are not even in the top ten - lightweights really.

Posted by Laurel
Arlington, WA
871 posts

Clarinda's Tea room if you're near the bottom of the Royal Mile and need a little something to get you to the top. Someone reccommended we stay away from Deacon Brodies but we liked it anyroad and The Witchery.

Posted by Ruth
Portage, canada
48 posts

Have to mention First Coast on Dalry Road near Haymarket Station, It was a gem that I found at the end of a wet day. Fireplace, warm, delicious food; excellent service!

Posted by Susan
Atlanta, Ga, USA
1536 posts

You can have tea or lunch on the Royal Britannia-very nice and the yacht is definitely worth a visit. We also enjoyed the Witchery for lunch.