I beleive we have narrowed our search down to these two... I can't find a photo of the Lavanda cave online anywhere... I've done the homework on how far from bus/rest/beach/price, etc...just does anyone have personal experience or opinion on either of these? Thank you so much!
Chelidonia Villas is an excellent family-run complex of houses in Oia, very centrally located to the village square. My favorite is the Apollon House because of it's excellent private position for viewing the caldera as well as the village.
It's the white house: http://www.tinyurl.com/aefpdl
If you haven't done so already contact the Aroma Suites and ask them to send you pictures of the Lavender Suite.