I am a long time fan of RS and bought books, ebooks, dvd sets, and his backpacks (which I do not recommend). His approach is unique. He essentially allows you to set up your own package tour, with some down to earth advice about what to see and not to see.
However, travel is about exploration and new experiences. A "one size fits all" short tour is a little limiting. For example, Paris - when I go back now I don't get anywhere near the Eiffel, Louvre, or other hot spots. I have since discovered all kinds of other districts and experiences never mentioned. The same is true of entire countries.
Other guide books might have itineraries for foodies, hikers, drinkers, nature lovers, retired people, art lovers, history buffs, etc. There are books for scenic drives and books just for train travel.
I kind of feel that RS is coasting. He writes a great book and then makes minor updates and sells it as a new book the next year. I bought some of Rick's books 15 years ago, and I am not sure if much as changed at all. When I am thinking of buying a country book, I think myself "maybe I could wait a few months and get next years version in case there are any updates.". Meanwhile, I think the competition has gotten much stronger - other books are full of color photos, color maps, and details on each region. And then there are websites/apps like TripAdvisor.
I would be happier if one or both of these things were done :
1. If you buy an e-book, get free upgrades to the same book the next few years or indefinitely - since all you are getting is slight edits, and its kind of ridiculous to spend $20 after $20 for the same info. This would encourage me to buy all the country books I might ever want to visit without worry of obsolesce
- I think each year, a little more info should be added to each book to flesh them out and keep up with the competition. Suppose you are in Avignon, is it worth a day trip to Lourmarin where the "Year in Provence" guy moved to? If you're in Turin, is it worth it to rent a car to go on the Barolo wine trip, or north to the Italian alps and Aosta or drive under Mont Blanc? If you're in Italy is it worth going to Bari and the eastern coast of the lower boot, or Matara where the new 007 was filmed (more and more people say its a great area)? Or my original question - is it worth 1:40 of train time total to visit Valencia where I assume the oranges of that name come from, where El Cid died? Or in the Portugal book - it assumes you will fly in for a week - how about getting there via ferry or overnight train from Spain?