With a heavy heart, today I’m posting to advise visitors to keep train excursions to a minimum while visiting Catalonia, at least for the time being, so you don’t risk spending part of your limited time here dealing with delays or disruptions.
It’s not that nothing works, far from it. Trains are still running, and people are still getting around. But delays have become an everyday occurrence, and while mobility still exists, the reliability of the system right now is much lower than it should be. And we’re not talking about 15-minute delays. We’re talking about trains that simply never show up, or trains that suffer a technical failure and end up sitting still for two hours. For a feeling of it simply search online for current news on "Renfe Rodalies Catalonia delays"
BACKGROUND
Catalonia actually has two different suburban rail networks, which is important to understand when discussing the current situation: Rodalies and Ferrocarrils de la Generalitat de Catalunya (FGC). They serve different corridors and are managed by different administrations.
The problems currently on the spot affect Rodalies, the commuter rail network operated by the Spanish state railway company Renfe.
In recent months, Rodalies has experienced frequent delays, cancelled trains, speed restrictions and infrastructure failures affecting thousands of daily commuters around Barcelona and across Catalonia. Signal problems, track incidents and emergency maintenance works have become increasingly common. For many people who rely on the system to get to work or school, reliability has deteriorated dramatically, in some cases to an untenable level.
One key point that is often misunderstood is how the system is managed. The problem is structural, not something that appeared overnight. The Rodalies infrastructure is owned and managed by the Spanish state through Adif, and the service is operated mainly by the state-owned company Renfe. As a result, the key decisions about investment, infrastructure maintenance, signalling systems, and rolling stock ultimately depend on the central government rather than the local administration, the Catalan government. In practice, it can only define the level of service it wants, such as frequencies or timetables, but it does not control the tracks, signalling, or trains themselves. Those are precisely the elements where most of the failures and disruptions tend to originate.
When disruptions occur, replacement buses are usually deployed. In practice, however, this often becomes chaotic. Information is inconsistent, buses arrive irregularly, and capacity rarely matches the number of passengers affected. These contingency operations are the responsibility of the rail operator, Renfe, sometimes with support from local bus companies and authorities. Passengers usually reach their destination eventually, but often after long waits, confusion and a fair amount of stress.
Many analysts and local officials argue that the current crisis is the result of years of underinvestment in the network. Between 2009 and 2023, a large share of the planned modernisation budget for Catalonia was never executed, leaving tracks, signalling systems, and tunnels outdated. The consequences are now visible: ageing infrastructure, frequent incidents, and reduced service reliability for commuters. Politics plays a fundamental role. Rodalies has become a recurring source of tension between the Catalan and Spanish governments, with disputes about funding levels, responsibility for failures, and the pace of transferring full management powers to Catalonia, agreed years ago.
part 1 of 2