Please sign in to post.

Public Transport from Carcassonne to Girona via Narbonne

Why are trains so expensive for travel between Carcassonne to Narbonne to Girona to Barcelona.
Primarily the route between Narbonne to Girona - each ticket costing around 60 to 70 euros.
I have heard that the local TER trains are much cheaper and pass through Portbou, but could not find any such options. Is there a website for local trains?

Also whats the best transport to take up, to see scenic views, I am ok to spend an additional couple of hours for my journey between Narbonne to Girona, if it takes me via Perpignan or Portbou or any other route.

Posted by
23369 posts

SNCF wants to put you on a TGV to go between Narbonne and Girona. You can take a TER from from Narbonne to Portbou for 21 EUR, and at Portbou you can take a Renfe regional train to Girona, for what I imagine will be a bit less than 21 EUR. SNCF won't show that because they don't sell Renfe tickets.

Posted by
29 posts

Thanks Sam, do these prices vary as the date gets closer, or are these fixed prices? Can I get the tickets cheaper online or at the ticket counter? Which website do I need to look at?
Also any suggestions on the scenic routes? Is flix bus road trip more scenic than train? Or do local slower train routes more scenic?

Posted by
23369 posts

Right now, Renfe is showing "Train not running" Portbou to Girona. Renfe website is famous for being difficult. They do run fast trains from Narbonne to Girona under the AVE brand, and these are about half the cost of French TGVs.
I know nothing about the Flixbus route. Most likely it runs on the motorway.

Posted by
30601 posts

Regional trains, including the TERs in France and the Media Distancias in Spain, have fixed fares and no assigned seats. They cannot sell out, and there's no advantage to buying early. French TGVs and Spanish AVEs have variable fares and assigned seats. Sell-outs are unlikely, but escalating prices are not. You can observe this in action by going to the websites below and pricing out the same trip for today or tomorrow vs. weeks or months from now.

https://www.sncf-connect.com/en-en for France

enter link description here for Spain

Renfe is, as already mentioned, sometimes flaky about displaying connecting routes. You could take a look at thetrainline.com to see whether it does any better. However, it charges (modest) fees and I'm not sure it shows all the departures, especially the less expensive ones. I'm just suggesting it in case it shows connections renfe doesn't display.

Posted by
29 posts

Thanks Sam & acraven, for your inputs.
But could you let me know how to book the TER trains? For now on trainline I can only see the following

Carcassone to Narbonne - its approx 24 pounds for 2 on IiO.

Narbonne to Girona - its approx 180 pounds for 2 on Renfe, the TGV are around 236 pounds.

Carcassone to Girona - its approx. 250 pounds for 2 on TGV .., so unsure on how to book the tickets on TER..

Do we know if these are on the higher side or usually need to expect this price. Also these prices fluctuate, so was wondering how can I find the TER fixed price tickets..

Posted by
23369 posts

You can only book TER as far as Portbou. DB is showing a connection at Portbou to Girona operated by Renfe, but when you go to Renfe, it says "Train not running".

What is your travel date?

PS, I have located timetables for train service between Portbou and Girona. The R11, and the RG1, operated by Renfe Rodalies de Catalunya. Seems like there are plenty of trains, and nothing shows up on scheduled maintainence, but I cannot find fares. I will PM correspondent Barcelona resident and see if he can help.

https://rodalies.gencat.cat/web/.content/02_Horaris/horaris/R11.pdf
https://rodalies.gencat.cat/web/.content/02_Horaris/horaris/RG1.pdf

Posted by
3438 posts

Important!: THIS IS A CROSS-BORDER (=INTERNATIONAL) JOURNEY

There are two approaches:

DIRECT TRAIN
You have two options, both high-speed trains: either AVE (RENFE, Spanish operator) or TGV INOUI (SNCF, French operator). Each one has its own website, or you can also try trainline.com

INDIRECT TRAINS
Alternatively, you can go with the French regional train service TER to Cerbere -at the border- and there, at 5 minutes walk, switch to Rodalies in Portbou, the RENFE regional train service in Catalonia.

TER, which in France is the equivalent to RENFE's in Spain: commuting and regional trains. There's no "European" info website for these types of services. Thus, for the French stretch, you can use TER's website https://www.sncf-connect.com/en-en/ter, and for the other stretch you can use https://rodalies.gencat.cat/en/inici/index.html


RODALIES

Schedules Portbou-Girona -so yeah… take all of that with a pinch of salt, given what I said earlier
https://rodalies.gencat.cat/en/horaris/index.html?origen=79315&desti=79300&dataViatge=2026-04-10&horaInici=0
(Change the date to your convenience!)

Fares: at the bottom of the page above.
Summarising: 9€ for MD trains (=less stops in between) and 7€ for R trains (=stops at every station)


IMPORTANT:
Travelling by train in Catalonia these days? Bit of a gamble, honestly.

For reasons I won’t get into now, the RENFE-Rodalies network is, well… a mess. Years of neglect to the infrastructure by the Spanish government, especially here in Catalonia, have dragged the service down to the point where it’s hardly not fit for purpose. And just when you think it couldn’t get worse, the pile-up of incidents over the last couple of years has forced them to finally deal with it… by launching works and repairs on pretty much every line at the same time. Great timing.

The result? Right now, taking a train on RENFE Rodalies feels like an adventure sport: delays, cancellations, replacement buses packed like sardine tins, or buses that just… don’t show up when they’re supposed to. To be fair, there is another operator, Ferrocarrils de la Generalitat de Catalunya (FGC), running different lines on a separate network, and those work like a Swiss clock (for example, the classic tourist trip to Montserrat). But that’s a different story and doesn't serve the area you're now interested in.

So yeah, a commuting train trip in Catalonia with Rodalies right now might go so-so and get you there more or less in time, or with a short delay… or it might go completely sideways and leave you stranded halfway, waiting for a bus with everyone else who had the same bad idea.

Your trip might turn out acceptable… or a complete train wreck. Sad to say, but that’s the daily reality for millions of Catalans right now.

If you decide to use RODALIES, keep an eye to the Service Updates here: https://rodalies.gencat.cat/en/alteracions_del_servei/index.html

It’s happening on the high-speed lines too, just a bit less. So much so that RENFE used to have this nice policy where they’d refund your ticket if an AVE train was more than X minutes late… yeah, that’s been quietly scrapped. A Madrid–Barcelona train that’s supposed to take 2h30 can now take 3… or even 4. And the best part? It’s completely random. Some trains run quite on time, others… not so much. Kind of like a lottery, but without the prize.

And bus? sadly not much better. Historically, the demand for a bus line in Portbou has been negligible, so the existing service isn't very convenient. There is a bus line, SARFA, but it connects to Figueres only. There you'd need to switch to another line, TEISA, to continue to Girona. Perhaps not the most convenient if you're carrying luggage up and down.

Posted by
23369 posts

Thank you, Enric, for your input. A local's perspective is very valuable.

Posted by
11762 posts

Renfe is less expensive than SNCF, so you can take a French TER which is a local train, from Carcassonne to Narbonne and catch the Renfe train from Narbonne to Girona. Two Renfe high-speed trains per day make this run. French trains are known to be more expensive than its neighbors.

Posted by
29 posts

Thankyou Enric for sharing the detailed information, will certainly have a look, it's very useful

Sam, my travel dates are as follows

Flying into Carcassonne on 23rd April
Plan to leave for Narbonne or Girona on 26th April (still looking into options if better to spend 2 nights in Girona and 1 in Narbonne or vice versa or spend entire 3 nights in one location.

on 29th April - From Narbonne or Girona, based on how the plan pans out - Leave for Barcelona.

Leave Barcelona fly back home on 2nd May.

So, most of my train journeys would happen between 26th April and 29th April.

Elizabeth - Thanks for the suggestion, will check out the option as well.

From

Posted by
1 posts

Hello!

Today I caught the train Narbonne to Portbou (about £9 each). Then caught a regional train from Portbou to Girona. At the moment the Roadalies trains are free while they do work across the network to recover from the last storm and get the services running better. When I got to Portbou the lady gave me a 10 pass ticket. I think the free tickets are for the rest of April and are valid for regional trains across Catalonia (don't quote me on that though). The train from Portbou was 10 minutes late and obviously the whole journey was a few hours longer than the fast service but I would 100% do it again to save the money. Hope this helps you! The rest of the blog gave me the confidence to take that route so thanks :)

Posted by
3438 posts

Thanks, chels_matty! Glad you were able to travel without any issues.

Yes, since January, they’ve been extending the free travel within the six zones in the metropolitan areas of Girona, Barcelona, and Tarragona. But as everyone says: what’s the point of it being free if you never know whether you’ll reach your destination or end up on a long, complicated journey that takes hours?

Posted by
29 posts

Hi Sam,

I was checking on the TER trains, the prices do vary each day, these are not fixed. So not sure if I go to the station will these be fixed price for both my travel from Carcassone to Narbonne, and then from Narbonne to Portbou?

chels_matty, did you book the trains online for travel from Narbonne to Portbou. Also from Portbou to Girona or barcelona, did you book online, or was it covered as part of Roadalies network, where you used your free tickets?

Posted by
29 posts

Enric,

All these trains on TER and Roadalies, do I but the tickets at counter or do I book these online?

Thanks

Posted by
3438 posts

For Rodalies you buy at the station. For TER I believe you can purchase online at the SNCF website (French rail operator)