Please sign in to post.

Madrid or Barcelona for someone who doesn't care for museums?

I love this site, and Rick's videos but I don't share the same affinity for art or museums as he does. I love history, but prefer to see it where it appears organically. (architecture, places, etc..)

I'm pondering an early June fly into Europe, and right now Madrid is only $150 but I don't know if it's city I would like? Barcelona looks very pretty, and I like it's on the sea. I'll fly home out of some city elsewhere a couple weeks later, maybe Zurich or Munich.

Are these places worth a couple of days each even if skipping museums which appear to be the top draws to both?

To give some color.

Cities I've loved (Venice, Florence, Rome, London) (most of Italy really)
Cities that disappointed (Milan, Dublin)

Posted by
1291 posts

I wouldn't call Barcelona pretty, but it sounds like more your type of place (and mine). Edit: although not famous for its Roman sights to the extent other Spanish cities are, there are quite a few (including one underground in a museum, sorry); plus there are a lot of mediaeval sights, early modern parts, all the modernism places, of course, and some Civil War sights such as a refuge bunker. I'm not sure if there is anything from the Moorish period, but generally historical sights are in abundance in Barcelona.

If the flight to Madrid is a bargain, that doesn't mean you have to stay in the capital. There must be over score of flights from Madrid to Barcelona each day, some as low as €40 at the moment for June, so you could arrive in Madrid and then just get another cheap flight onto Barcelona. Or you could go into Madrid city from the airport and get the fast train to Barcelona - again many services every day.

I think splitting time with two days in each is the worst of both worlds. Better to plump for one and devote all your time to it. Whilst Madrid isn't as interesting a city as Barcelona itself, it does have several historical day-trip options such as Toledo and Segovia so might appeal as a base.

Posted by
1942 posts

Both are worthy of a few days. In Madrid you can take walking tours, visit Toledo or Segovia on day trips, explore the city and markets and visit the Retiro Park. However, at least visit the Reina Sofia Museum to see Guernica. It is amazing in person. I would suggest the Prado as well just to see Velazquez Las Meninas.

I really didn't visit any museums in Barcelona but still had a great time, There is so much to do in Barcelona that you won't be disappointed.

Posted by
27047 posts

During the nine full days I spent in Barcelona in 2016, I went to at least five art museums, but I spent more time tracking down modernista architecture. There are dozens of fascinating building interiors and exteriors to admire; fortunately for tourists with limited time, a lot of the buildings are private and can only be seen from the outside.

I also especially liked the tourist office's Barri Gotic walking tour, which gives you snippets of the city's history, and the 4.5-hour Civil War walking tour offered by IberiaNature (Nick Lloyd's company).

I don't find Madrid as visually interesting as Barcelona, but Toledo (which is worth 2 or 3 nights) is much older and has a lot of beautiful Mudejar architecture. Segovia, Cuenca and Alcala de Henares are other good day-trips from Madrid. (Cuenca is a good overnight for visitors who like modern art.)

Posted by
285 posts

Great thank you all for these answers and suggestions, sounds like I'll dig a little deeper! Transit between the 2 cities is very affordable by air or train. Thinking then on to Geneva, Annecy, and then deeper into the alps for some hiking.

Posted by
5580 posts

Madrid is lovely and lively, but I think if you don't enjoy museums, Madrid would be pretty low on the list in a country that has many more interesting and historical cities. I didn't go to any museums in Barcelona unless you count the Modernista sites as museums. Both Madrid and Barcelona have some interesting day trips though I think Barcelona has more. I would highly recommend a day trips to Girona (gorgeous, medieval walled city situated on a river) and Montserrat (monastery on top of a mountain) There are sites in Barcelona that are very unique to Barcelona.

Posted by
1942 posts

I think there are people who like Madrid and those that don't care for Madrid. I loved Madrid, it seems more like a normal big city town in Madrid. My parents didn't care for it however they loved Barcelona which seems to more tourist-friendly to me and seems more a mixture of cultures like NYC. Perhaps it helped that I spoke Spanish and my parents don't.

There are many different things to do:
Visit the big El Rastro flea Market on Sundays(watch out for pickpockets)
Visit the Palacio Real(Royal Palace) gardens and Cathedral next door.
Walk around the Plaza Mayor
Walk around the San Miguel Market and buy small tapas or olives.
Take a walking tour from the Tourism Office.
Grab a coffee and pastry from La Mallorquina on Puerta del Sol-a Madrid institution.

Madrid may not have the distinct architecture or surroundings of it's Catalonian rival but has it's own charms. I would set aside several days for Madrid just to see another view of Spain. Buen viaje!

Posted by
5580 posts

Great info Heather. I'm bookmarking for future trips! I think we will find ourselves in Madrid a few times since that is our "gateway" to the rest of Spain.

Posted by
3890 posts

For someone who is more interested in history or nature, but not so much museums, here would be some of my recommendations for day trips around Madrid and Barcelona.

Near Madrid:
Toledo - a stay for a night or two in this medieval town will feel like living in history, especially at night.
Roman town of Segobriga - an intact Roman town that was completely abandoned during the very early middle ages, only recently begun excavations, relatively undiscovered by most foreign and even local tourists.
Cuneca - 12th century medieval town built on the steep side of a mountain, which makes for a very unique place to spend a day or two.
La Ciudad Encantada - close by to Cuenca, one finds a protected geological site with many large and unusual mushroom rock formations, many films were shot here, including Conan the Barbarian.

Near Barcelona:
Tarragona - has some of the better Roman ruins in Spain, including a Roman amphitheater and Praetorium tower. The medieval center also makes for a nice place for walks and dining.
Pont del Diable - close to Tarragona, there is an intact Roman Aqueduct. You can actually walk over it like a bridge (if you dare). The surrounding forested area is great for some casual hiking too.
Girona - ancient city in northern Catalonia, it has an impressive Cathedral, towering medieval walls, and narrow winding streets, The Onyar river snakes it's way through Girona, giving the town a Florence-esque feel
Empúries - the site of the ancient ruins of a Greek colony from the 6th–3rd century BC. It's quite unique as the ruins sit right on the Costa Brava overlooking the sea.

Hope this gives a few ideas! :)

Posted by
285 posts

Oh this is great, thanks for all the ideas! I really appreciate it!

Posted by
11294 posts

First, Barcelona and Madrid are as different as San Francisco and Los Angeles, or Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, or Melbourne and Sydney, or... As always with such rival city pairs, you may love both, hate both, or like one but not the other, and you won't know until you see them for yourself. Just be aware that asking someone from Barcelona what they think of Madrid is akin to asking someone from Dallas what they think of Houston.

I like Madrid not only for its musuems (great as they are). I also enjoy the big city vibe, the parks, and walking around various neighborhoods. La Latina (in Ricks' book) is Balgnadeshi and hipster; Chueca (not in the book) is gay; and Salamanca (not in the book) positively purrs with wealth. All were fun to walk around and explore.

If you want a different kind of art museum experience, there's the Joaquin Sorolla Museum, which is in his former house. It has an Andalusian style patio outside, and while it has his artwork inside, it's still feels very much like a house. https://www.esmadrid.com/en/tourist-information/sorolla-museum