The RS Guidebook is not to hand so I can't evaluate the summary provided by the OP. Perhaps it is a misinterpretation of RS's meaning? Certainly, if the OP's interpretation is accurate, it is not my experience or that of the other posters.
The "Upper Room" ticket gives an entry time, no entry prior to this time, do immediately check for the entrance to the "Upper Room" area to ensure you will be there 15 minutes in advance. (The entrance is marked on the RS Guide maps - or if not there now, it was marked in previous editions). There were folks at my timeframe who were too late to join the tour. Afterwards, stay as long as desired. This is exactly what others have described above.
I was curious so I AI'd the statments/question asking for an evaluation. Disclosing source of following!!! This is Google AI as it says, mistakes can happen, but the answer makes sense to me based on recent experience and the answers provided by others above explaining their experiences:
The "VIP Status" / "Arrival as Early as Possible" Claim
The Reality: Rick Steves is referring to the fact that holding a ticket with the Upper Rooms upgrade grants you a privileged entry condition. You get to bypass the regular, often hours-long walk-up line and head straight to the Puerta del León.
The Catch: You cannot simply arrive as early as you want—you must abide by the 60-minute early arrival window. You will not be allowed to enter the Puerta del León before that window opens for your specific time slot.
Enjoy - I especially liked the "Upper Rooms" and gardens.