Please sign in to post.

Waterproof Hiking Boots or Mesh Hiking Shoes?

Posted by on

We will be tackling mild to moderate hikes during our trip in August, including across the Isle of Canna, the Fairy Pools of Skye, the Hermitage Walk in Dunkeld, around Arthur's Seat and through Dr. Neal's Garden in Edinburgh, and lots of city walking in Edinburgh and Glasgow.

I recently had bunion surgery on both feet (fun!) and I am very sensitive to how my shoes affect my walking. I recently bought the Merrell Moab 3 mesh sneakers and they are the best shoes I have ever had. I'm actually excited to go outside and walk, which is something I have not felt in years! They have great cushioning underneath the sole of my foot, have a nice big toe box, and are extremely light weight. However, I have read that they can get soaked through pretty quickly.

Obviously, I am expecting rain at some point during our trip. Should I pay for the waterproof version of the Moab 3 hiking boot, or keep the shoe I know I love? I would like to wear my hiking option on the plane, and only have a comfortable flat option for our nice dinners in my travel backpack. (I'm thinking Aerosoles Big Bet Flats, but up for suggestions...)

Posted by
1965 posts

I haven't hiked the trails you listed but have spent 2 weeks in the Outer Hebrides and Highlands. I can't imagine not wearing waterproof footwear. How are your feet going to feel if your shoes get soaked through? I can't imagine it will be comfortable. Also, how are they going to dry over night if they do get soaked through? I also travel with a backpack. I wear my waterproof shoes on the plane and have one pair of ballet flats or sandals as my nice shoes for evenings or city visits.

Posted by
16700 posts

I'm with Trotter....I'd go with the waterproof version. I, too, have not hiked the trails you have listed but have spent several weeks in 2 different years on Orkney and Shetland. Waterproof sneakers were a necessity along with a good tread.

I have awful feet and have settled on Altra Lone Peak waterproof shoes for my go-to vacation shoe. Since the Moab 3 works for you I'd not try to switch for your vacation, just throwing that out there. They are zero drop so might not work for your feet.

IF you can't find these locally, I'd suggest ordering from Zappos which has free shipping and free returns. Oftentimes the waterproof version of a shoe will fit a little tighter as the waterproof membrane takes up some space.

editing to add: Ooops...forgot to say if you do decide to go with the non-waterproof shoes, I'd have something more than the little flats as your back up shoe. Also, you'll want to take the insole out every night and may need to assist with the drying process.

Posted by
902 posts

I haven't hiked that area but once but my approach is breathable, quick drying and lightweight for summer hikes (even if water and rain is present) and waterproof only for cold (and maybe shorter hikes.) If it really wet-- say pouring or wet stream crossings-- all shoes and boots will get soaked. Gortex and the like trap the water in and then it takes a long time to dry. There are tradeoffs and folks have different opinions with most recommending waterproof. I call them the blister crowd! And they call me nuts so, yeah, it's up to you.

Good luck and happy travels!

Posted by
2617 posts

Hi,

My husband and I have the Merrell Kiruna iI insulated waterproof hiking boots and we just love them. I don’t think they make that model any more but I wouldn’t hesitate to buy Merrell waterproof hiking boots again. Our Merrell hiking boots are so comfortable and they are definitely waterproof. Merrell has become our go to brand. The model that I bought came in wide which accommodated my bunion.

Posted by
1589 posts

You will likely regret not having waterproof hiking boots in Skye. I live in mine. Sneakers do not have sufficient ankle support for most Skye hikes.

Add Reply

Please do not reply to violations of our Community Guidelines.