Please sign in to post.

Tiree or Canna?

There was a contentious discussion of this trip awhile ago, and we decided to include all the favorites. I've settled on our next trip (May 2028) except for the ending. It's Ireland's turn for 2027, and I prefer to have the plan in place for booking right that trip. After visiting all the "near" islands of Bute, Arran, Gigha, Kintyre, and Mull, we will leave Mull on Sunday morning via Kilchoan to visit the Ardnamurchan peninsula, then the choices:

Choice 1: Stay at Clacaig Inn, return to GLA, return car, and fly to Tiree on Monday. Three nights there, then one night on Coll, then fly to Oban and take Scotrail to Glasgow. Or we could skip Coll and take the ferry to Oban.

Choice 2: Stay in Arisaig, ferry to Canna on Monday for two nights, then stay one night in Mallaig or nearby and drive back to Glasgow. Maybe the ferry schedule to the Small Isles will change before our trip, allowing a second island or we could add Inverie as the fourth night.

Choice 3: Stay at Clacaig Inn, then head to Pitlochry, Grantown area for four nights before returning to Glasgow.

The overall music plan forces being in Arisaig or Clacaig Inn on Sunday night.

Posted by
212 posts

What a hugely difficult choice!

Have you looked at any images of these various islands in terms of which most appeals?

I’ve been to Tiree multiple times (we had various family holidays there from my teenage years to my own sons being very young.Have visited Coll three times. Canna- a one day visit which left me determined to explore more.Eigg is also well worth considering.

Tiree is almost completely flat and known as akin to living on the deck of an aircraft carrier - the Hebrides are windy but Tiree beats them all.There are a few very small knolly hills but it’s great glory is its machair - the carpet of wildflowers on the grassland behind the beaches.And the silvery white beaches themselves which are glorious- one for every day of the year (not quite!) It’s also one of sunniest places in Britain, May especially.Fantastic light.Views to the ethereal Treshnish Isles are fantastic.

Coll is well worth including also as it is so different despite being adjacent.It’s a very appealing, rockier landscape - more like Assynt - with lovely beaches.It’s north end is stunning with views to mountainous Rum.

Canna is a little dream of an island and if you enjoy walking, easy to explore on foot (your only choice as no cars allowed.Eigg is the same.) It’s a very quiet island with a good cafe/restaurant (Cafe Canna.) The bluebells in May are stunning especially round John Lorne Campbell’s one time home, Canna House.There are some archaeological sites beyond the grounds.The sail from Mallaig out to Canna is magnificent as you pass the Black Cuillin of Skye.

The cliffs on Canna are the nesting place of puffins and views to nearby Rum are outstanding.

Choosing is certainly a nice problem to have!!

Posted by
1275 posts

I've looked at all the things we'd like to do on both islands, and both have enough to keep us busy. I'm constantly frustrated at the difficulties of getting around on the Small Islands, and I'm inclined to defer Canna for a future trip where our calendar is more flexible and can visit more islands. The risk is that the next trip might never happen.

Thanks for reminding me of all your great blog posts (they showed up in my email but not on the forum?).