My wife and I (and our small dog) will be traveling to Portugal for the first time in September for three weeks. My wife has MS so a car will be a necessity, even in towns like Porto and Lisbon where public transportation is advisable. I may be open to using Lyft on our first day in Lisbon to get to wherever we wind up staying and then collecting the car the next day.
We plan to go all over the country, from Porto to the Algarve to the eastern mountain villages such as Idanha a Nova and Belmonte. (I am in the process of getting Portuguese citizenship because my mother's side of the family descends from Portuguese Crypto Jews who escaped the Inquisition hundreds of year ago and those towns hold particular interest to me)
Using a variety of booking sites, I am noticing a huge difference in quotes I get from the mainstream agencies (Avis, Budget, Hertz) to the more "local" unknown firms, like $900 vs $400. Booked a reservation through Global Rent A Car but am also looking at Sadorent, Ausacar and many others. Given that about two years ago, I went through a claim nightmare with an Avis car I rented from CDG that I thought American Express would cover as part of their car services, I plan to purchase some comprehensive CDW from an English company that will cover any damages.
Can anyone tell me from personal experience if this is the wrong approach and whether I should stay with the tried and true? or offer any additional advice that might make this approach successful? Thank you in advance,