We have 9 days to wander the Algarve region, from 12/9 - 12/18, and plan on hiking around Monchique, the south coast, and part of the Rota. I would also like to see Tavira, but could do that on a day trip. We will have a car. What town(s) would you suggest we base in? Typically we like to spend a few nights in any given location so we don't waste too much time moving.
Are you planning to use a vacation rental or hotel?
With a car, I would prefer a vacation rental with free parking over a hotel. I would also prefer to stay in one base and not switch accommodations. Using a single base to visit the different towns is not a problem because the Algarve is very easy to drive. This is low season and you could get a better rate if you stay longer than 7 days. Cleaning and other fees with each new rental change can really add up.
We spent 4 nights in Lagos in September, 2023 and really enjoyed it. We could have easily chosen a different town in the Algarve and it would have been fine.
Vacation rental(s)/Airbnb(s) are our first choice. We will want the flexibility of having a kitchen and hopefully laundry. Free parking also a plus. I hadn't considered the fact that we could save significantly by not having multiple cleaning/admin fees. I guess the big question is, do we want to be somewhere really quiet or near lots of shops and restaurants for the times we aren't on the trails?
The towns are pretty small. We stayed in a luxury 3 bedroom apartment with a view in a residential area about ten minutes walk to downtown Lagos.
You are going in the middle of winter. It is probably pretty dead, except for visitors during Christmas week.