Please sign in to post.

Misidentification of Pope Francis

I am watching Portugal's Heartland. Rick just referred to Pope Francis. WRONG! He was Pope Francis.

Posted by
23398 posts

"Portugal's Heartland" was filmed in 2018. Francis was the Pope at that time. Rick could not see into the future.

Posted by
2 posts

As I understand it, the first time a Pope uses a new name, neither he NOR anyone else cannot use I since he (nor anyone else) has no way of knowing if any who follow him will use the same name. For what it's worth (about what you are paying for it), Peter is generally considered the first Pope and since no one has used that name since, he is not Peter I.

Posted by
178 posts

Rick just referred to Pope Francis

He was Pope Francis

Those are literally the same words.

Posted by
227 posts

Rick just referred to Pope Francis. WRONG! He was Pope Francis.

I am glad we, you and Rick all agree that Pope Francis was indeed Pope Francis. So that’s all good..

Posted by
3134 posts

So should the vast library of Rick Steves PBS shows be edited to reflect current events?

Posted by
8144 posts

I do not understand the post. . . This is a first time poster.

Posted by
11659 posts

@jules, As I read it (after much head scratching) the OP is saying that Pope Francis deceased last year, so the video should say 'the former (or late) Pope Francis."
The poster may not be aware that (s) he was watching an old video.

Posted by
933 posts

I think the OP forgot to type "the first" in his original post. Rick refers to "Pope Francis the First" in Portugal's Heartland. OP's point is that Pope Francis was (and still is) the only pope called Francis and, therefore, should not be referred to as "the first" (or Pope Francis I) but simply as "Pope Francis."

At least I think that's what the OP means!

Posted by
6618 posts

I think the OP forgot to type "the first" in his original post.

Yes, I think you are correct and the OP made a mistake in their first post just like Rick made a mistake calling the pope ”Francis the first”.

It just proves, ”To err is human …”.

I am sure that Pope Francis would have forgiven both the OP and Rick for their errors.

Posted by
1995 posts

Yep, but at the time this program was filmed he was alive. I’m not understanding what you’re trying to get across here….

Posted by
104 posts

This is one of the more bewildering posts I've seen here. Apparently Pope Francis was Post Francis?

Posted by
18140 posts

I think the OP forgot to type "the first" in his original post.

Agree. Rick apparently - and erroneously - referred to the since-deceased pontiff as "Pope Francis the First" (or Pope Francis I" ) but he'll only become a "First" if a future pontiff also chooses to be a Francis: Pope Francis II. Then the recently deceased Francis - currently the ONLY Francis in the papal line - will become the differentiating Francis I.

But as you wisely pointed out, Laura, ”To err is human …”. Pretty sure Francis would cheerfully have forgiven Rick his wee blunder, as should our OP? My goodness, it's a travel show and not World Peace...something we all desperately could use a healthy dose of right now! :O)

Posted by
13499 posts

If one is going to be picking nits, one should proof read what they write.