Please sign in to post.

Why "no photos"?

Many shop windows in Italy had signs saying "no photos". Anybody know why?

I was just reminded of this because I saw this same sign in San Francisco in a boutique imported food store--most of the items from Italy.

Posted by
290 posts

Generally it's because there are artisanal, handmade products, or original designs, so they want to avoid copies. It happens a lot in Venice with the masks.

Posted by
7049 posts

I think people in general, and business people, are very sensitive about any private images uploaded to social media because they cannot control any unpredictable outcomes.

Posted by
1059 posts

When I was in Milian, I stopped by a Ferrari store. I have a friend who owns a Ferrari. I thought it would be funny to take a picture of a toy Ferrari and tell him I bought a Ferrari. It took the store clerk about 5 seconds for him to tell me no pictures in the store except one of a real Ferrari. Oh well. I decided not to buy the toy Ferrari.

Posted by
7324 posts

Your title gave me hope, all too briefly, that Italian museums were going to not allow any more photos. Ah, being able to enjoy art in the museums without all of those selfies.

Posted by
7737 posts

Sometimes it's because they don't want photo-takers to take up space that might be used by someone who was actually going to spend some money. But I agree that most often it's for protection of the images of artisanal designs.

Posted by
312 posts

I'm a marketing professor and take photos of American brands in other countries for my classes; I got told "no photos" in a McDonald's in Milan!

Posted by
15125 posts

In Volterra, some friends of mine passed a store with original artwork and started to take a picture of the window. From inside the store we heard someone yelling "No photos." But we couldn't see them.

Posted by
7333 posts

I've seen No Photo signs in Manhattan floral design windows. But the Supreme Court has ruled that there is no expectation of privacy in a public place. That affected efforts to prevent photographs of U.S. bridges and buildings after 9/11.

Since "Rick" is partly about proper behavior while visiting other cultures, it would be helpful to know if these Italian merchants are overreaching, or just implementing real, local standards of conduct.

Posted by
3519 posts

They want you to buy their products, or in the case of museums and churches the photo albums they have assembled for you. It's all about the money. ;-)

But their rules because it is their rules. I follow them.

Posted by
11613 posts

Whether the merchants are "over-reaching" or not, if they don't want photos taken, are you going to invoke the proper legal ordinance? Or just politely move on?

Posted by
440 posts

Happened to my Dad at a Rolex shop in Knightsbridge London i think it was incase you take pictures then go back and smash the place up and rob them, but for ceramic things it most likely is a case of protecting their work from copycats

Posted by
7049 posts

Most items are mass produced these days, even ones that look unique....it's even arbitrary to define what is "artisanal" since it has become not much more than a marketing term

Posted by
23305 posts

What I really like to ban is the selfie-stick and perhaps a ban on a certain group that seems addicted to them. That is what should be ban.