Please sign in to post.

Venetians fear ‘museum relic’ status as population drops below 50,000

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/aug/10/venetians-venice-italy-fear-city-becoming-a-museum-as-population-falls-to-50000

Campaigners say Italian city’s remaining residents feel ‘suffocated’ by effects of tourism.

The remaining inhabitants of Venice’s historic centre said they fear becoming like “relics in an open museum” now that the population is expected to drop below 50,000 for the first time.

Once the heart of a powerful maritime republic, Venice’s main island has lost more than 120,000 residents since the early 1950s, driven away by myriad issues but mainly a focus on mass tourism that has caused the population to be dwarfed by the thousands of visitors who crowd its squares, bridges and narrow walkways each day.

Venessia.com, an activist group that for years has campaigned to preserve Venice’s heritage, has kept track of the population decline and said the figure, now at 50,011, would fall below 50,000 by Friday.

“We don’t have a precise number but, according to our calculations, and using data from the civil registry, it will go below 50,000,” said Matteo Secchi, who leads Venessia.com. “We have been warning about this for years … we don’t want to give up, but no administration has managed to reverse the trend.”

Secchi said that those who remain feel “suffocated” by an “economic machine” that has focused on tourism. He said it had left residents grappling with a high cost of living, a lack of affordable housing, and led to businesses that sell essential items being replaced by souvenir shops.

“Tourism is a double-edged sword because you take money but at the same time you expel all the activities and space for [the residents],” said Secchi, who described Venice as “a cash machine”. “There are those who are not from here but own a home, rent it out and then spend the money elsewhere.”

Venice authorities this year announced a plan to attract remote workers to the city, but it appears to have made little impact. “This kind of thing is OK, but we need an epochal change and for the council to bring in significant measures, such as offering financial incentives to property owners who, say, only rent to Venetians,” said Secchi. “The danger is that we are becoming extinct, soon we will be like relics in an open museum.”

Venice council dismissed the population concerns, arguing that the number is boosted by foreign students and daily commuters from nearby Mestre, and that the civil registry does not include those who may dwell in the city for a significant part of the year but who are not registered as a resident.

An electronic ticker displayed in the window of the Morelli chemist has recorded the population on Venice’s main island since 2008. “Today it’s at 50,011, down from 50,022 last week, and for sure it will go under the 50,000 threshold in the next few days,” said the chemist’s owner, Andrea Morelli. “The drop is very demoralising. I remember Venice as a child, when the local population presided. You would go for a stroll in St Mark’s Square and see people you knew. Not any more.”

Posted by
2516 posts

Sad to read this, I spent 10 days in Venice last August in a lovely hotel in the Santa Croce neighborhood near the San Stae Vaporetto stop. It was the most relaxing vacation in a beautiful, magical place!

Posted by
3113 posts

My wife and I no longer go to places like Venice, which are pretty much fossilized towns with more tourism than life.

We are going to some touristic places in Italy. But we are avoiding Venice. We like smaller towns, where we get some of the history, but it's not a disneyland.

Posted by
2645 posts

Lucky you to have seen it before the crowds. A lot of younger people will be seeing it for the first time soon. The best we can do is go off season

Posted by
1297 posts

“My wife and I no longer go to places like Venice, which are pretty much fossilized towns with more tourism than life.”

I do think that in a brief visit, Venice can feel like Disneyland et canals. It takes a while to discover a more real Venice. Artisans create work there, there is a huge student population, the Biennales draw people from all over the world.

But you do dig a bit deeper to find venues and places that are away from the tourist, “three nights are enough”, hordes.

Posted by
166 posts

It is sad that locals are leaving and feeling suffocated. I love Venice and realize that makes me part of the problem so I do what I can to tread lightly and spend money with locally owned businesses. Take a reusable water bottle and fill up at the public fountains, stay 3+ nights at a hotel or B&B, shop at the Coop, it’s fun! There is an organization called Venezia Autentica that lists businesses run by Venetians to help you find them.
I hate to think that the best way to help a city I enjoy so much is to stop visiting, but maybe my next visit should be my last.

Posted by
3113 posts

The worst thing, of course, is that so many places are being "Venice-cized". You go to the tourist district, and see nothing but high-priced international stores (Coach, etc). This is so annoying. I never shop at these places in the US. Why would I shop there in Dubrovnik? The locals are being driven out.

It's terrible in the USA. There are certain retailers that are found nationwide, that drive out local businesses. Subways are everywhere. I eat there now and then. Panera (which I also like), certain chain Mexican restaurants, etc. Every city has those malls with nothing but what you see in the "standard strip mall". Some cities seem to have NO local stores, like Phoenix.

In some places, like some of Italy, non-Italian eateries are not allowed in the antique district. This is good. I would go further.

Do not patronize any non-local stores on travel.

Posted by
9051 posts

Anyone have a solution? We seem to always destroy the things we love the most.

I recall reading a statistic several years ago that said 90% of the restaurants and shops on the Grand Canal were owned by foreign investors and large companies. Money will always trump social concerns.

Posted by
16167 posts

People always like to complain.

In 2020 there were ZERO tourists in Venice. In this article from May 2020 one Venetian gondolier was quoted saying that “without tourists Venice is dead”.

The issue is how many young Italians would wish to move to a city center where you can’t use or park your car in front of your house and where it takes forever to commute since you can only travel on foot or by boat? Also how many young generations of Italians would like to move to houses built centuries ago which often do not have modern day amenities and that cost an arm and a leg in maintenance costs every year? Have you ever wondered why old historical centers in any Italian town, including those near large metro areas, are losing residents? People are not willing to give up modern day conveniences and living in an area where car use is restricted or in old houses that are certainly not as comfortable as modern ones and often in need of expensive maintenance work. Those living conditions are not attractive to many except for to those who plan to spend only a few days/weeks on vacation or those who can afford major upgrades to bring the houses up to modern living standards.

Posted by
347 posts

One thing that does drive up local housing in places like Venice is the conversion of homes to tourist rental properties. I suspect that's had an impact on housing costs here.

And what Roberto said as well. Venice cannot be a very convenient place to live, especially if you have children, even if you could afford it.