Umbria - suggestions to schedule?

There are too many places to see on day 4. Keep Bevagna and Montefalco. Also, another day visit Norcia.
We spent two wonderful weeks in Spello and did not visit all the towns you list. There are so many to choose from. We had a car.

We stayed at an agriturismo near Spoleto in October 2021. We visited Assisi by car, and parked in the free lot outside the walls. It seemed that cars and trucks inside get walks didn’t exactly want to share the narrow streets with pedestrians, and there were often either no sidewalks, or they were so narrow that it was only practical to walk in the street. Spello and Bevagna didn’t have that problem.

A couple of the days were very rainy, and COLD, so be prepared for that possibility.

Suki is right - trim down the Day 4 destinations. It’s too bad that Spoleto isn’t on your daytrip agenda. It’s fascinating and atmospheric, and with a car, you n the area, I’d put it at the top of my list, with Spello and Bevagna tied for a close second. Assisi was interesting, but it wasn’t a pilgrimage destination for us, so it was nice, but not essential, and the other towns were more rewarding to visit. For Spello, we parked down below (free!) and passed the fascinating ancient entrance gate and walked up into the town. Maybe your lodging gives you better options.

Bevagna was different, because it was level, and not a hill town. Get there before lunch for medieval paper-making, candle dipping, etc. demonstrations in the buildings surrounding where the ancient Roman amphitheater stood.

Thanks to all for the replies. Will think about redoing and adding Spoleto.

I am praying for no rain!