Please sign in to post.

Tuscany vs. other wine regions

Copying this from the RS facebook page and cross-posted in the France forum.

Dear fellow RS followers, my husband and I are looking at a trip to Europe next year and would like to visit wine country this time. We would have a Tuesday-Sunday trip in September 2018 (coming from Munchen Sat-Tues).

For those that have seen both (or researched both), would you recommend Burgundy or Tuscany? We've narrowed our search to these regions.

If it helps, we are both active wine-drinking travelers on the downhill side of our mid-forties. We've visited Italy and France before but not these regions. We are not particular about our wine and enjoy everything we taste.

Thanks in advance and cheers!

karen

Posted by
906 posts

I have not been to Burgandy but I live in Oregon with Pinot Noir everywhere. I have been to Italy a few times.

In the time you have you could hit the Barolo areas of the Piedmont (Asti, Alba), then to the Tuscany wines of your choosing, perhaps Sassicaia, chianti, Brunello, or Nobile, then down to Umbria for sagrantino or classic whites. It would be a great trip.

Posted by
118 posts

Hi, Gordon! I have visited your wine region and have a club with one of the estates out of the Willamette Valley. Very tasty wines. DH and I love Pinot Noirs.

I appreciate your feedback on the area. I will look into those options that you've provided.

ETA: Where would we base ourselves? We want to stay in an agriturismo, if possible. We did this in Pianoro outside Bologna and it was perfect. Also, are there any bike routes between wineries? Most of the vehicle tours I have seen have been out of Florence or Siena. We want to avoid ALL driving when wine tasting as DH and I are not great at the spitting.

Cheers!

Posted by
3716 posts

Please do not for a moment think that the Pinot Noirs from the Pacific Northwest of the US taste anything like the ones in Burgundy. In your thread on France, I mention my love of Pinot Noirs but I should have written French Pinot Noirs. If you go to Burgundy expecting the Pinot Noirs to taste like the ones from Oregon, you will be sorely disappointed or happily awakened to the impact of terroir on wine.

Posted by
483 posts

|In the time you have you could hit the Barolo areas of the Piedmont (Asti, Alba), then to the Tuscany wines of your choosing, perhaps Sassicaia, chianti, Brunello, or Nobile, then down to Umbria for sagrantino or classic whites. It would be a great trip.

Let's see. Tuesday, Wednesday, Thurs, Fri, Sat, Sun.

Winery visits in Piemonte (BTW: Asti is not in the Barolo area... Alba is just next to it), tend to be multi-hour affairs, as they are not set up for Sonoma/Napa style taste and dashes. They will tour you the vineyards, the barrel cellar, the fermentation tanks, the whole 9 yards. They will taste you what they make. It may be 10 wines, as I experienced at Ada Nada in Treiso, where we stayed. It will likely come with some cheese and sausage, and be a whole morning or afternoon. Alternatively, there are regional enoteca (5, though Grinzane Cavour, Barolo and Barbaresco are probably the only ones worth visiting, as Mango is only open on F-Su and the Roero one is kind of out of the way. These can be banged out a lot more like a Sonoma/Napa tasting room. Additionally, some of the towns, like Nieve and La Morra, have tasting rooms connected to wineries for that faster style of tasting.

Tuscany, I have not done. But I'd recommend picking one region, not splitting time. There's a lot of driving in Piemonte (one of the most beautiful places I've ever been) and I'm sure it's similar in Tuscany/Umbria. It's a few hours drive from the one to the other, of not necessarily the most interesting driving.

I'd pick Tuscany over Burgundy, even though I'm more familiar with Burgundian wines. Tuscan wines, beyond Chianti, kind of demand a rosetta stone, for the sheer variety of grapes grown. Hundreds of varietals... I feel that Tuscany will produce wine of better value than Burgundy, but have no evidence to back that up.

Posted by
118 posts

Thanks, all.

JHK, I definitely do not expect the Pinot Noirs to taste the same. The wine in Oregon tasted very different to me than the wine from the central coast here in CA so I expect the wines to taste different (and hope that they do). I find that I am almost never disappointed by wine. I either have a very uneducated palate or a very open-minded one. Thanks for the heads up!

Max-thanks for the advice. For the days of our trip, you can assume that Tuesday will be largely a travel day from Munich and Sunday will be a travel day back to CA. That still leaves 4 solid days of touring around. I think I am most concerned with driving in the area. It sounds like everything is pretty spread out. That was what is appealing about Burgundy. The wine road connects so many wineries it seems like an easy bike ride to a handful. However, the wine options in the Tuscany area seem much more varied. Thanks again for the advice.

Posted by
782 posts

You might look at Villa Antinori in the Greve region which is the oldest family owned winery in the world,great tasting and tour with equipment designed by Leonardo daVinci on display on the cellar tour.We also tasted at Il Broglio which has villa with a great display of medieval armor along with great wines.The driving aspect has been well covered by the other posters.
Mike