Hello,
I am planning our trip to Tuscany and trying to decide if we should include a visit to Cinque Terre on our own for a couple of days versus a long day trip from Florence. If driving, we will have to deal with parking and since we will have large luggage thinking it would be better to stay in La Spezia versus in one of the villages. Alternatively, we can take the Freccarosa directly from Rome that stops in Florence at the beginning (Day 3) or at the end of touring Florence (Day 6) and the rest of the Tuscany region. We are planning to pick up and return vehicle in Florence as it is considerably more expensive ($400 more) if our pick-up and drop-off location is different. We are flexible on where to pick up our vehicle but Florence has the most frequent and robust train routes.
Here is our current plan without Cinque Terre.
Day 1: Arrive Rome & stay 2 nights
Day 2: Tour Rome (have been several times)
Day 3: Freccarosa to Florence
Day 4: Florence sight seeing
Day 5: Lucca - via Regional Train (maybe also visit Montacantini Terme)
Day 6: Depart Florence for accommodations near San Gimignano - Pickup Rental Vehicle
Day 7 to 16: 10 Days to tour Tuscany area/towns - San Gimignano, Volterra, Monteriggioni, Siena, Cortana, Montepulciano, Pienza, Montalcino, visit a Hot Spring, wine tours/tasting & a cooking class
Day 17 : Depart for Florence to return rental vehicle and take Freccarosa to Rome
Day 18: Fly back home
Any input or suggestions are welcomed!! TIA