Please sign in to post.

Speaking with Google Translate and I am still awful!

I am practicing up on my Italian before the trip. I am playing around with Google Translate, and for probably a number of reasons, I am awful. When I speak Italian, even if I am reading a phonetically spelled phrase, the things that I am saying is wild and quite funny!

So, I want to be respectful and try to say some things in Italian, but knowing my abilities, or lack of, should I attempt once and then using the Google Translate app and show the person? It feels rude to shove a phone in front of someone, but these bad pronunciation attempts must get old for them. My partner is better using this app, so maybe I let him do the speaking.

How do people handle it when they try but just can't grasp it in a functional manner?
Any suggestions would be appreciated.

Edited to add , I actually think I am speaking correctly, but this app keeps having different ideas!

Posted by
456 posts

I expect it will go better than you think. When you're in a store or restaurant the context gives a lot of cues. You're probably asking the price, to pay for the item, for a table, etc and so even if you pronounce the sentence with a thick accent they will likely figure out what you're trying to say. Google Translate, on the other hand, is context-free. You literally could be trying to say any valid sentence in Italian so it has to guess what it might be.

Posted by
20 posts

Bill G, That makes so much sense. I was struggling so much to be "understood" I wasn't thinking about the context.
Thank you

Posted by
257 posts

You can also use Google Translate as a simple text messaging platform, except you do not send.

You type your words into the app and then hit translate (to Italian in this case) and your words translate to the (probably) accurate words in Italian.
Shoe the translation to whoever you are conversing with.
Worked for me in both Italy and France.

Posted by
7548 posts

While your willingness to learn a few bits of the language and to be polite are laudable, I think you may be expecting too much from yourself, and too little from those you will meet. Sure, learn the polite social words and phrases, but unless you work really hard to get to extremely remote places and/or in unusual situations, as a tourist I think you will probably find that many (usually most) of the people you interact with can understand and speak English just fine - often almost as well as you (presumably a native English speaker) can. IME the younger the person you're looking at, the better their English will be and the easier they'll slip into conversation in English. If the person has a lot of gray hair, maybe expect less.

IME few people you will be dealing with (almost everywhere in the world) are really interested in using google translate or other technical translation tools. It just slows things to a crawl and gets in the way of getting things done, it's awkward, and most people do not have the patience for it. 99% of them would rather just use their simple-if-imperfect English as they do with almost every other tourist they see. Only when you've both completely run out of common language skills (they'll have plenty) and patience (depends on the situation) will they be in the mood to resort to gizmos.

I once bought a brand new, expensive (multi-thousand dollar) musical instrument in a Tokyo instrument store where nobody spoke more than a few words of English (and I only spoke even fewer words of Japanese). We got by just fine with pointing and pantomime, writing down numbers, a bit of shrugging and smiling, and a willingness to make things work. I did resort to google translate when we got down to details over price, payment, receipts, taxes, and other small things, but the actual need for that was remarkably minor. I left the shop with my beautiful (and frighteningly expensive) new instrument with a smooth transaction behind me, my only worries were dropping the thing or having it crushed on my way home via the subway.

In short, you will be fine. Don't get too stressed about the so-called language barrier. It's mostly gone, even in places you would expect it to be a problem. You can always resort to google or drawing pictures in a pinch.

For better or for worse, English is just about anywhere that a tourist might find themselves. Don't be too hard on yourself if you can't rattle off beautiful-sounding Italian conversations. Use your hands to express things more than you might at home (careful with gestures that might be mis-translated, eg what we think of as the "OK" sign means something entirely different in some parts of the world...), smile and be as charming as you can be. It'll all work out.

Posted by
598 posts

DeepL Translate is a much better choice than Google Translate when you need context-aware accuracy.
For Italian specifically, DeepL excels at capturing formal vs. informal tones (like tu vs. Lei) and mapping out natural, fluid sentences.

Posted by
2238 posts

Italians will always appreciate the attempt to speak Italian - no matter how haltingly. You can get pretty far in the usual vendor transactions - buying things, food and drink - even with very little shared language. Don't let your hesitation hold you back from saying "Buongiorno" or "Buonasera" as appropriate when entering a store or place of business as this is basic manners in Italy. Saying it badly is way better than saying nothing. Trying basic phrases and exchanging pleasantries will be appreciated and the more you do it the easier it is.

I would definitely fall back in typing things into Google Translate - or having others speak or type into it - for important questions like train or bus options and details, farmacia questions or complicated instructions. People who work in service settings are pretty familiar with the tools. I once had a museum security guard in Spain approach me with translated instructions as to where to start a museum tour while we were debating.

But be bold and get as far as you can without it and see how it goes. Italians love to talk and if you don't say anything they assume you are either bored or boring.

Be brave and have a great trip,
=Tod

Posted by
3359 posts

Another important thing about meeting others in Italy or any country is to wait until you are close to start speaking. Don't start barking out comments from across the room. Be polite. I find that this is so helpful.

Posted by
148 posts

Practise the following phrase and you'll be fine 90% of the time at least in hotels restaurants etc. (It's just imperfect enough they'll know you're being sincere...extra points for good pronunciation 😄).

"Mi dispiace signore/signora ma sono americano e non parlo bene l'italiano. Lei, parla um po l'inglese?"

Posted by
9593 posts

Don't sweat it. Learn enough to greet people, thank people, a few basic phrases, and inquire if they speak English, otherwise, you put yourself in a no-win situation.

In my early attempts, I get through the greetings and ask a basic question...and am hit with a rapid fire response I have no hope of understanding or responding to.

While, yes, learn enough to be polite, also be polite enough to be incompetent to the point that they know your skill level is low. Leading someone on, then forcing them to switch language and repeat everything they took time to say, is impolite. Maybe OK if it is clear you are trying to learn, but hotel clerks, shop people, waiters, and most of the people you will encounter, do not want to be teachers, they have a job to do, and they usually have a more than average grasp on English.

I do not think I would worry about using Google Translate or other apps, unless the person simply does not know any English and other simple attempts at communication have failed. At that point, you both acknowledge a communication gap, so technology is acceptable.

Posted by
2701 posts

Maybe give the free Duolingo a shot. There are practice lessons for speaking and listening in addition to the regular lessons.

I agree with others learn the basics and you'll be fine. Most Italians, unless your in a truly remote area, will have better English than your Italian.

IMO, if you start a conversation in Italian ( or French or whatever) beyond the pleasantries, you'll soon discover that the responses are spoken so quickly you'll be lucky if you understand every third word. Tell them your still learning and ask them to please speak slower.

Posted by
20 posts

Updated Reply:
Thank you everyone for all the helpful responses and the reassurance that my attempts might be adequate. JeanM also just made me aware that after I ask a question, I might not understand the answer.
I will take the advice here and as David in Seattle pointed out, there are many ways to effectively communicate.

I was overthinking it and I thank you for pointing that out.

Posted by
227 posts

I agree with the other comments about learning a few phrases to be polite. I have found Google Translate to be very useful for menus and other signs. You just point your phone and the menu and it's translates it to English.

Posted by
801 posts

Side note:
When last in Italy I was trying hard to speak a simple phrase when the Italian gentleman replied in English “I do not know this language you speak”.

Posted by
20 posts

Renee, that is exactly would would happen to me!! LOL Glad I'm not the only one!

Posted by
148 posts

Posted by Windyram
Belgium
09/09/26 01:52 AM
570 posts
Lei, parla um po l'inglese?
Parla un po' di inglese?

Cheers mate and thank you most graciously for the correction albeit quite unnecessary as I'm actually fluent in Italian...in my post I clearly stated the phrase was purposely imperfect. Because if you were to tell someone in perfect Italian that you don't speak Italian well and thus why you're asking them to struggle by in English, they might think you're just being "a typical American tourist who thinks the whole world ought speak English" 😉

Posted by
18235 posts

Most people you will be dealing with in tourist spots will speak at least some English. Younger generations (school age/college age kids or anybody under 35) are very likely to speak English well enough to help you. Just learn the very basics like Good Morning, Good Evening, Thank You, You are welcome, Do you speak English?, and, most importantly, Where is the bathroom?