Hey there!
First, thanks for your input. It's always great to hear the thoughts of other travelers.
Second, I already know that one week is not enough for Sicily, but it's what we have as part of a longer trip we'll be doing to Europe in the late Spring/early Summer.
We have one week in Sicily and we'll be renting a car. Have narrowed it down to the eastern part of the island (plus Agrigento), to make it reasonable and realistic. Palermo and many other lovely spots, sadly, will have to wait. We will fly into Catania, and drive out of town that same day.
Here's where we would like to go: Siracusa/Ortiga, Ragusa or nearby w/day tripping to Noto/Modica/Scicli, Agrigento, and some kind of Mt. Etna visit: vineyard trip, or lower level mountain hikes at Refugio Sapienza (or both if possible!). It would be nice to be able to stop at Villa Romana del Casale either on our way to, or coming back from Agrigento. I don't know how long that will take... it's not a huge priority, but would be nice.
Rough itinerary we were thinking of:
Siracusa/Ortiga (2 nights) and drive to:
Ragusa or one of the other towns and day trip to Ragusa (2 nights) and drive to:
Agrigento (1 night or 2 nights?) A little uncertain about this b/c the drive from Ragusa to Agrigento is longer and don't know if we'll have time to tour the temple area that same day or need to hold off until the next, which would also mean leaving late afternoon to head to Etna area. Might be too much. Maybe we stay somewhere on the road between Agrigento and Etna? In a place that doesn't get much tourist action, which really has appeal for us. In any case, the last/final stop would be in the Etna wine area, maybe:
Randazzo (1 or 2 nights) or somewhere else nearby, if someone has a suggestion, and spend the remainder of time either enjoying the wine country, which I hear is beautiful and/or doing some light hiking at Sapienza before heading back to:
Catania, where we will fly out.
How does this sound? The other thing we were thinking of is to start at Etna and then go to Agrigento, etc. kind of backwards, but we're open. (We'll be coming from Spain so jet lag should not be an issue by that point). What do you think? Any specific suggestions? Or advice? Things we should drop, or add? I know we're missing many things: Taormina, etc., but you have to make sacrifices to have a trip that allows you to actually enjoy where you are. We'll be driving plenty as is.
Anyway, thank you so much, and we'll look forward to your responses.