Please sign in to post.

Real-time translation apps

Has anyone had experience using the real-time function of translation apps like Google Translate. Microsoft Translator, SayHi, etc.?

Supposedly you can have a conversation in two different languages and the apps will translate back and forth in real time. I experimented a little on my own, saying a phrase in English, then Italian, etc. It was basic since my Italian is very limited. For a short conversation with simple words it did work.

Has anyone used it in Italy, or other countries?

And a follow-up that came to mind from another thread I posted:
How do translation apps handle the "familiar vs formal" concept. They can't distinguish the social setting, so which do they use?

Posted by
15631 posts

I've used Google Translate.. It worked the way it was supposed to.

Don't worry so much about formality. You just have to make yourself understood. The other person will know you don't know the language.

Posted by
6949 posts

How do translation apps handle the "familiar vs formal" concept.

Most translating apps default to the formal, although I've found that Google Translate can sometimes separate the two. For example, if you wanted to translate "Mrs. Jones, you've got a lovely daughter," it will recognize the formal title and give you formal pronouns. However, if you say, "Anna, do you want some pizza?", it will probably give you the familiar.

Posted by
207 posts

I've used it for written translation in Italy and Greece when my ideas were beyond my capabilities.

I type in my sentences and translated english to Italian/Greek and showed the resulting translation to the person with whom I was conversing.

Posted by
264 posts

I used googletranslate frequently while in Puglia and Sicily last fall.
It worked great for small translations - like in the grocery store when I was looking for certain produce or talking to the butcher. Everyone had a smile with going back and forth. Usually I just held up the phone with one word "bacon?" "small mozzarella balls" etc. and the sweet clerks would lead me to the right place.
But when we had a problem with our rental apartment and the agent and I had some long discussions, she refused to slow down her speech (we were face to face) and google translate could not get what she was saying.

So one of the main things in conversation is to speak slowly on both sides.

Posted by
32253 posts

Jim,

In my experience, the translator apps have improved a lot over the last few years, but they're not perfect. Using simple phrases and avoiding slang helps to get an accurate translation.