We are pretty sophisticated travellers to Europe over the last 30 years (this will be our sixth trip to Italy in 3 1/2 years), but I have never experienced what seems to me unreasonable terms for a room in Monterosso al Mare before the high season even kicks in; i.e. one place wants a full non-refundable payment 3 months in advance of stay, one takes cash only, one non-refundable deposits, etc. I like the protection a credit card payment offers, and I don't pay in advance for a hotel room. None of this was ever the case anywhere else we've stayed in Italy, including two trips to Lake Como, which is very touristy. Most of the places I have checked online don't post their rates or take confirmed reservations online; I have to inquire by e-mail, which leads me to believe rates are jacked up for American inquiries.
Can any one recommend a nice, fair place to stay within easy reach of the train station in Monterosso? We are not high maintenance people requring a fancy room, but I don't like being taken advantage of. We will be staying in Genoa for the week in April, but I'd like to spend a couple of nights in Monterosso, rather than just do day trips to CTerre, but as I re-read my post, I am getting turned off from staying there!